Support SF BayView
Donate or Subscribe to SF Bay View
Follow Us Twitter Facebook

Alice Walker fights anti-Palestinian bias

September 30, 2011

by Dennis Bernstein

The Palestinian children’s drawings capture the oppression and brutality of life under Israel’s economic blockade and military attacks. But under pressure from pro-Israel groups in the community, the Museum of Children’s Art (MOCHA) canceled the exhibit, which had been months in preparation.
Alice Walker is Pulitzer Prize winning poet, author and activist. She participated recently in the U.S. Boat to Gaza, which was a part of the Freedom Flotilla, to break the Israeli embargo on the Gaza Strip.

Last year, a flotilla was attacked by Israeli commandos and a number of people were killed and wounded. Walker’s boat was stopped by Greek authorities before it could traverse the eastern Mediterranean to Gaza.

DB: I want to start with the recent attempt by the Children’s Museum of Oakland to prevent Palestinian kids from showing their art. You wrote a very moving piece on your website. It was very personal. Could you just briefly outline what you wrote and your response to this censorship?

AW: Well, I was basically saying that the children need to have exposure of their art because it will be a wonderful way to help them heal from the trauma of being bombed and watching their friends, and sometimes parents, die.

And it’s unconscionable that any adults, especially in this part of the world, and lo and behold in Oakland would want to deprive these children of a venue in which they could expose some of their grief and some of their pain and, of course, some of their art.

And so I just very strongly urge all of us to go to see this art. I’m not sure where it will be shown.

DB: There was an opening, I should tell you, around the corner at a beautiful gallery. There were about 500 people, there was a marching band, there was beautiful food out front, and a lot of people marveled at the extraordinary art that was shown around the corner from the Children’s Museum.

I think they had a better shot there. And now they are getting requests for it to be a traveling exhibition around the world. It is incredible. …

Can I ask you to share the personal part of what you wrote? Because I have seen as a teacher the impact of very troubled kids, oppressed kids, kids who have faced difficult times being able to get through it through self-expression.

And this, the part of this that bothered me the most is that the exhibit was advertised, the invitations were sent out, the workshops were set up, the kids were excited and they were told “No, it wasn’t going to happen.” Could you share the personal side of what you wrote?

AW: There are a couple of things. One is I was injured myself as a child. I was playing cowboy and Indians with my brothers and one of them accidentally shot me in the eye. And that led to a lot of suffering and a lot of grief and a lot of pain.

And I started writing poetry at that time when I was 8 or 9 years old. And my relatives encouraged me to share it, to show it to people. And that was a part of my healing. And so I could easily see that that could help these children.

The board of directors of the Museum of Children’s Art released a statement that defended rather than apologized for their censorship. Board Chair Hilmon Sorey called the drawings “graphically violent and sensitive works,” and he cited the museum’s lack of policy towards such content as the reason for the exhibit’s cancellation. But these concerns had not stopped the museum from displaying the art of Iraqi children a few years earlier.
That having the venue denied to them is a way of making them remain locked in their own private suffering. And this is something that adults with money, in this case, could do to these little kids.

And they are doing it, but it is at great risk to their own souls to do this to children, to force them to remain unexpressed or to try to force them to remain unexpressed in their suffering.

The other part that was so, that came to mind as I was writing this essay was how in 1939 Marian Anderson had been denied …

DB: The great singer …

AW: The great contralto. She had been denied a venue at the Constitution Hall, at Constitution Hall in D.C. by the Daughters of the American Revolution, who were just upset that the place was going to be integrated.

And so Anderson’s friends, including the president, [Franklin] Roosevelt, and Eleanor Roosevelt came to her defense and she was allowed to sing on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial.

And she actually attracted 75,000 people of all colors and kinds and everything. And it was one of the biggest turnouts ever, up to that time, at the Lincoln Memorial.

And so I was just reminding us that these bannings and attempts to censor people, they often backfire. And that is something that we should remember.

It strengthens us as well, because we begin to see the forces that are against us. They are fleshed out; they come out of the walls and woodwork, wherever they’ve been hiding and pretending to be upstanding, kind and generous people.

They suddenly stand revealed as the really very narrow hearted people that they are, and so we don’t have to be fooled. And it’s a great thing not to be fooled by people – to have that little bit of consciousness about who is likely to try to trip you up as you start climbing towards your freedom. Yes.

DB: And just to take off on what you said, it is either you have a very frightening and difficult and terrifying, tragic experience happen to you and either you have a chance to express it to people who care and want to hear it or it gets forced down inside of you and manifests as an illness in various ways. So it can make all the difference in the world.

AW: It makes all the difference in the world. And in fact, one of the things that you learn from having some fairly dreadful things happen to you is that you can survive and you can still be happy.

And I like to tell very briefly a little story of a leper that I came across in Hawaii on the island of Molokai – a man whose face had just about been dissolved by his illness, and his expression of just absolute joy was shining through what was left of his face.

And he said, “You know one of the things I have learned from this hard life here is that you can have these terrible things that happen to you and you can still be happy.”

Now this is good news for anybody but especially for a child who feels just completely squashed by an imperial power that bombs its communities and its schools for 22 days, non-stop, a child that just has lost parts of its body.

To know that somewhere there is this teaching and that there are these people and that someone is waiting for them on the other side of the trauma to share with them what they have gained.

You know, you don’t just lose, you sometimes gain a lot from suffering. And they can stand with you and that’s why I love the Middle East Children’s Alliance (MECA).

The campaign to censor the exhibit had the support of major pro-Israeli organizations in the California Bay Area. The Jewish Federation of the East Bay publicly bragged about their success via Twitter.
I love the Middle East Children’s Alliance because their commitment to these children and to making it clear, not only to the children but to the adults in the world, what it is that we need to be doing together, which is bringing them along, helping them stand, and helping them to see that there is still a possibility of being joyful little kids.

DB: Why did you decide to join that flotilla?

AW: Well, I did it because I really believe that it is our responsibility. When the world is out of whack, as it is almost everywhere you look, what do you do? And where do you place yourself?

And how much do we believe what we say we believe about wanting to fight the good fight for the freedom of the people of the world and the happiness of the people of the world.

And I had been in Gaza, and I had been in the West Bank and I had met my tribe of poets and singers and musicians and philosophers and historians and children – and we’re just people.

And, you know, people everywhere deserve to be free of fear. They deserve to be free of people taking their land and bombing their schools and taking their water.

And so it felt like, given my own background in the South with the segregation – and I’m sitting here right now looking at pictures of both my parents – that I have an obligation given how much I deeply understand this kind of pain to try to be present even if we don’t get to where we were trying to get to.

We didn’t get to Gaza. But we did get 10 miles off the coast of Greece.

DB: And you were turned back.

AW: We were turned back by armed commandos from the Greek Coast Guard, and we never got to be in confrontation directly with the Israelis. But they were working against us the whole time. They had been sabotaging the other ships and making it really hard for us to move.

And yet there again, I can’t be discouraged. I feel so much that if you just get off your couch, if you just leave your house, if you just head out to stand with your neighbor, even if they are 10,000 miles away, if you head out, there is a way in which you are already there. Your intention is so important, and the movement forward is so important.

DB: You know, Alice, I’m usually very afraid about everything. Whatever I do, I tend to do it, but I’m frightened. Now you got on a boat knowing that the last round of the Freedom Flotilla faced extreme violence by Israeli commandos. A number of people died, were wounded. How do you deal with your fear? Were you afraid?

AW: Of course I was afraid; we’re all afraid. But there is this realization that an earthquake could just right this minute just cover us all up with rubble, we could be sucked out of our car by a hurricane, we could be drowned in these floods that are happening.

In other words, there’s a way in which you have to start to see now that danger is really everywhere and it’s in every moment, so it is better to, I think, to then approach those areas that are dangerous and difficult in that spirit, that well I could lose my life here too at home.

Alice Walker – Photo: Monica Morgan, WireImage
And also now the thing that I find really remarkable – and I felt this way in Mississippi 40 years ago – when you reach the other people who are as determined and as dedicated as you are, with the love that you have, it’s a kind of heaven.

And it’s not to be missed if you can possibly manage to get to this kind of circle of people who have evolved. I felt on the boat, in the presence of such goodness, such amazing spirit and heart – that it made it worth whatever the sacrifice might have been. I mean if I would go, I would go with these people, and how blissful really.

DB: Finally, and I guess this is the hardest thing for me to understand: We are seeing several recent reports surfacing out of Israel, really put together by the Israelis describing a program, an expanding program of midnight kidnappings and torture of children as young as 12 years old by Israeli soldiers.

Sometimes they are taken to the basements of the settlements, illegal settlements, and questioned and masked, but they are taken by hooded soldiers. And my question for you – and I don’t know if there is a real answer – but what drives a people to go to these lengths to silence children and to repress freedom?

AW: Well, I think that one of the things that probably should not have happened for so long is the constant reiteration of the Holocaust.

I think if we had a slavery industry so that so often you would hear horrible tales about the enslavement of Black people, like every time you turn around, we would have some incredibly crazed Black people who would be doing some much more violent things because of the anger.

I think that whatever happens, you are never permitted to evolve beyond your rage. So everything becomes an obstacle to your liberation from your own rage. So you turn into quite dangerous entities in society.

Alice Walker is the author of many books of poems and prose, including “The Color Purple,” “A Poem Traveled Down My Arm,” and “A Poet Encounters the Horror in Rwanda, Eastern Congo and Palestine/Israel.” For a list of Alice Walker’s work, go to She spoke with Dennis Bernstein on Flashpoints, a news program at Pacifica Radio broadcast every weekday at 5 p.m. on KPFA 94.1 and Host Dennis Bernstein can be reached at


7 thoughts on “Alice Walker fights anti-Palestinian bias

  1. abushaar

    May God bless Alice and Dennis. Thank you for printing this interview! I am aware it takes a courageous editor to allow anything critical of the Israeli government printed for fear of some community pressure.

  2. davem1962

    "And I had been in Gaza, and I had been in the West Bank and I had met my tribe of poets and singers and musicians and philosophers and historians and children – and we’re just people."

    Sadly she excludes a lot of them from her tribe.

  3. Dr B

    Does Alice realize that Israeli children in kindergarten are forced to dive into bomb shelters every day because of missile attacks form their Palestinian neighbors? Dies she support their art?

  4. deavman

    A bunch of idiotic mostly false statements uttered by the useful idiot of the day.. Nothing more.. But the sad part is all the do-gooders of the world will gleefully accept her description of the situation not because they love the "little children of Gaza " but because they only have hatred in their hearts . Dennis Bernstein is obviously doing what is so good at which is pandering to the Anti-Israeli propaganda with absolute lack of restraint and consideration of the facts. He call himself an "investigative journalist" , I doubt he is neither a journalist or investigative, but that does not stop the "Bay View" of publishing this nonsense, thus doing great disservice to its readers. In all this the perfect trio for misinformation.

  5. E.Hartogs

    How poetic the life of gays, women and Christians in Gaza. So romantic to have a gay romance, punishable by Sharia law. How poetic a women must feel to be called a prostitue for wearing jeans. How closer to God can a Christian feel than as a Christian under Sharia law?
    So different than living in a Jewish country, where one can freely practice any religion, pose nude for Spencer Tunick, or walk with the shortest mini's imaginable. Such a shame that those Jews respond on their citizens being attacked by thousands of rockets and mortars, eventhough no Jew is to be found in Gaza.
    Tell me who your friends are…

  6. Annie

    I have a lot of respect for Walker – her writing speaks for itself but obviously this is a case of a woman with a good heart who is just so incredibly naive about the real situation. She has fallen head over heals for the whole Palesinian “we are the victims” nonsense and really – who could blame her? their propoganda machine is working 24/7. the truth is that if Palestinians accepted a Jewish state as their neighbor and to live in peace instead of terrorist attacks and rockets raining down on Israel, there would have been a Palestinian state a long time ago. It’s a shame that like a lot of good people, Alice does not recognize that. The Palestinian goal is to OBLITERATE Israel. nothing less. Israeli children are traumatized by the rockets that fall indiscriminantly on their towns for OVER 8 YEARS. Palestinians are not armed with only their “hopes and dreams” as the rhetoric goes, Alice.

  7. Jake in Jerusalem

    Alice Walker won a Pultize Prize… for fiction. Her misplaced sympathy for children in Gaza is based on fiction and Arab propaganda. If Alice Walker is concerned about Gazan children who were under under attack for 22 days, one wonders where her concern is for Israeli children who have been under bombardment from Gaza for the past decade! One million Israeli civilians – men, women, and childen – have been living in bomb shelters or within a 15-second dash to one for years. I have seen these kids; their haunting eyes say everything that has to be said about living in the constant shadow of Islamo-Fascist terrorism. Alice Walker doesn't care about Jewish children, dead or alive. One wonders why.


Leave a Reply

BayView Classifieds - ads, opportunities, announcements