by Michael Tagawa
Richard Aoki, Michael Tagawa and Bobby Seale at the 1996 Black Panther Party Reunion
After a few weeks of reading hundreds of pages about Richard, it finally sank in that I had wasted a lot of time – not because I wasn’t concerned about Richard’s legacy, but because it became obvious that my concern about his reputation was not particularly relevant.
Richard’s reputation as a strong principled person is intact. Now some were wavering in their feelings about him, which is understandable, because so many knew him as a tower of strength and almost super-human in his accomplishments and dedication to helping others.
Therein lies the dilemma for many people. Many feel that Richard could never have been a “snitch” or anything less than the god-like person he sometimes seemed to be. He was principled, articulate, active, decisive, smart and physically involved and one hell of a nice guy with a great personality.
Richard Aoki and Michael Tagawa at the Black Panther Party 40th anniversary reunion in October 2006 – Photo: by Carole Hyams
So was it possible he was an informant for the feds? Sure, it’s a possibility.
Is there any solid proof? Nope, just a lot of speculation, innuendo and 277 pages of U.S. government memorandums, most of which are heavily redacted.
So what I see is a situation where, on the one hand, Richard was a possible U.S. government informant and, on the other, a human being who dedicated his life to serving, helping and encouraging others to be the best people they could be.
But … “Maybe he was a snitch!” somebody says. Maybe. We don’t know for sure. And so what? Richard was a human being like all of us, and as such he was entitled to possibly making a “bad” choice.
Elbert “Big Man” Howard joins life partners Nina Laboy and Michael Tagawa at the Seattle Black Panther Party’s 40th anniversary celebration in April 2008. – Photo: Carole Hyams
Now this is the bottom line: What Richard did for the people he served is known. There is half a century of proof out there in the form of inspiring thousands of people to work for justice, in the schools and communities, not just in the Bay Area but across America. He was an exemplary humanist activist as proven by a half century of evidence in the form of people, institutions, policies, ad infinitum, that were helped, inspired or improved upon.
For those who would denigrate Richard for the possibility and perhaps the reality of making an error in judgment, try to remember that he was, first of all, a human being.
Michael Tagawa, Aaron Dixon and Emory Douglas at the Seattle Black Panther Party’s 40th anniversary celebration in April 2008 – Photo: Carole Hyams
If you can’t appre- ciate this great man for what he did accomplish
for all of us, I have only to say to you, go fuck yourself
! Next, get on your high horse, go down to the shoreline, walk across the water to your throne, and contemplate your own perfection … away from us imperfect humans.
Michael Tagawa speaks at Richard Aoki’s memorial service at UC Berkeley in 2009. – Photo: Carole Hyams
Rest in peace, Richard Masato Aoki, Field Marshall, Black Panther Party.
All Power to the People!
Michael Tagawa, Black Panther Party, Seattle
Michael Tagawa became friends with Richard Aoki at the 30th Anniversary Reunion of the Black Panther Party in Oakland in October 1996. Michael, who is Japanese American, was born in the Minidoka Concentration Camp, Idaho, prisoner number 11820-F. He can be reached via firstname.lastname@example.org.