Support SF BayView
Donate or Subscribe to SF Bay View
Follow Us Twitter Facebook

‘Mugabe: Hero or Villain’: an interview wit’ filmmaker Roy Agyemang

March 3, 2013

by the People’s Minister of Information JR

In the eyes of the international Western media, Robert Mugabe is the most controversial political leader of an African country. The president of Zimbabwe has backed agrarian land reforms that stripped thousands of white farmers, who benefitted from the colonization of the nation, of their land and returned it to the people – to the dismay of Western governments, colonizers and the Western media.

Roy Agyemang with President Robert Mugabe in his office 2008, web
Roy Agyemang with President Robert Mugabe in his office 2008
Roy Agyemang is a Ghanaian filmmaker from London who recently made the documentary film “Mugabe: Hero or Villain?” which is an in-depth look at this man. It recently screened at the Pan African Film Fest and won an award, and it will be screening in the Bay opening night at the Oakland International Film Fest at 6 p.m. on Thursday, April 4, at the Grand Lake Theater in Oakland. Here are a few words with Roy Agyemang, the man behind the lens …

M.O.I. JR: When and how did you become a filmmaker? Where were you trained?

Roy A.: I have been working in the media as early as 10 years old. I began in front of the camera as a child actor, then moved into presenting. I was one of the few Black faces on British television.

I trained at Ravensbourne School of Broadcasting in London, developing the skills as a director and cinematographer. Moving behind the camera was a natural progression for me and the best move I made. I had much more control about the stories I was telling.

M.O.I. JR: As a Ghanaian, what made you want to do a film about the revolutionary Zimbabwean President Mugabe?

Roy A.: Growing up in the U.K., the perception of Africa and its leaders had a profound effect on how kids acted towards me in the playground for being of African heritage. So from an early age I wanted to work in the media and show my friends there was more to Africans than being killed by Tarzan.

African politics was often discussed in my household. My parents left Ghana around the time of the coup that saw the ousting of Kwame Nkrumah in 1966. Since then the relationship between African leaders and the West has had its ups and downs. I was fascinated to understand how this often fractured relationship had to do with Africa remaining poor.

President Robert Mugabe in his office 2008, web
President Robert Mugabe in his office 2008
Robert Mugabe was once a darling of the West, a Nobel Peace Prize nominee, knighted by the Queen in 1994 and awarded several honorary doctorates from established institutions in America and Europe. I was intrigued to find out at what point did the West’s relationship with Mugabe turn sour.

M.O.I. JR: How long did it take you to shoot “Mugabe: Hero or Villian”? How did you get access to the top circles of Zimbabwean politics for the film?

Roy A.: I spent three years on the ground in Zimbabwe. It was the most challenging and most rewarding three years of my life. Getting access was extremely difficult. There were those who thought I worked for the British secret service. Others thought I worked for the BBC.

The fact that I stayed on the ground when the country was facing its toughest period economically since independence helped gain the trust of President Mugabe. It took almost two years to get the first interview with the president. I spent the following year travelling around Africa with Mugabe.

M.O.I. JR: What is the importance of this documentary in the scope of contemporary African politics?

Roy A.: Political independence of Africa began in the 1950s; some nations fought a bloody war for their freedom. The war for economic independence of Africa will be an even tougher battle. This film gives you a clear idea of what happens to a country when an African leader attempts to take control of the country’s natural resources.

M.O.I. JR: Since you were on the ground in Zimbabwe, how do you feel about the controversial agrarian reforms of Mugabe? Was this a necessary step for the nation to survive?

Interview day - Roy Agyemang greeting President Mugabe alongside Garikayi 2009, web
Interview day – Roy Agyemang greeting President Mugabe alongside Garikayi 2009
Roy A.: I didn’t meet anyone Black or white who disagreed with the principle of land reform. A situation where less than 3 percent of the population – of European heritage – controlled 80 percent of the country’s most productive land was not sustainable.

Land reform was completely necessary; some criticize Mugabe for taking almost 20 years to do it. Others criticize the methods by which land redistribution policy was implemented.

M.O.I. JR: How have Black people from the U.S. and Europe responded to your film? White people?

Roy A.: The response to my film in the U.S. and Britain has been fantastic, beyond my wildest dreams. My film goes against the grain of the powerful Western media. I get thanked for my objectivity.

After my recent screenings in Los Angeles, people have said to me they were ashamed to be American. They were disgusted with the policy of their government towards a small African country. I was pleased to see many white people in the audience at my screenings in LA. There were many things in the Zimbabwean story that they were not aware of.

M.O.I. JR: As a filmmaker, working with such politically powerful subjects, how do you attempt to keep your objectivity?

Roy A.: The Western view of Zimbabwe and its president has been consistently negative over the last 12 years. It was important for me to listen to the views of Zimbabweans – Black, white, young and old – and get a less sensationalist view of their country. Even those who disagree with Mugabe’s polices are utterly appalled at the Western propaganda about their country.

It was also critical to get the views of African leaders. It makes compelling viewing: the opposing views of African and Western leaders.

Roy Agyemang at the King of Swaziland's residence 2010
Roy Agyemang at the King of Swaziland’s residence 2010
M.O.I. JR: What kind of awards has this film received?

Roy A.: The film recently received the Special Recognition Jury Award at the Pan African Film Festival in Los Angeles

M.O.I. JR: Why did you name this film “Mugabe: Hero or Villian”? What is your take on the question?

Roy A.: Mugabe: villain or hero? I live in the U.K., where Mugabe is viewed as a villain. Spending three years on the ground, which also included travelling around Africa, I heard many people state that Mugabe is a hero.

My film is presented in a way where the viewers can make up their own mind.

African leaders that don’t conform to Western ideology are more often than not perceived as villains. It is only when they die that they are remembered as heroes, just like the great Kwame Nkrumah.

M.O.I. JR: How do people keep up with you online?

Roy A.: Twitter: @RoyAgy; Facebook: Roy Agyemang; www.mugabevillainorhero.com

The People’s Minister of Information JR is associate editor of the Bay View, author of “Block Reportin’” and filmmaker of “Operation Small Axe” and “Block Reportin’ 101,” available, along with many more interviews, at www.blockreportradio.com. He also hosts two weekly shows on KPFA 94.1 FM and kpfa.org: The Morning Mix every Wednesday, 8-9 a.m., and The Block Report every other Friday night-Saturday morning, midnight-2 a.m. He can be reached at blockreportradio@gmail.com.

2 thoughts on “‘Mugabe: Hero or Villain’: an interview wit’ filmmaker Roy Agyemang

  1. zunaith

    I am Zimbabwean working in South Africa. I have not seen the documentary but will comment on the above interview with Roy. The sentiment in Zimbabwe ever since the so called agrarian reform started is that it was done haphazardly and without proper consultation and engagement with the people. Rewinding back to 2000 where we had to vote for a new constitution and one of the issues that we voted a convincing ‘NO’ in the referendum was the unorganised land reform programme. That is when stuff hit the fan, Mugabe and his party saw the ‘NO’ vote as a sign of diminishing support for him and that is when the violent land grabs and violent election campaign started.

    The land reform has not benefitted the nation at all. Mugabe and his party comrades took over all the productive commercial farms and gave the zimbabweans crappy small farms with no equipment etc to promote self sustainance. At this moment he and his wife own a dairy farm outside of Harare near Norton which they seized from the white owner yet none of the people are benefitting from any part of the farm.

    Problem with Roy and Dali Tambo (a journalist based in South Africa) is that they do no get to meet the real Zimbabwean I am sure they are guided on who to talk to. Mugabe is no hero rather with the so-called independence we just replaced one devil (colonial government) with an even worse devil in mugabe. How come none of the Zimbabwean journalists, film makers with an opposing view to mugabe have ever been allowed access for a documentary/interview.

    Mugabe has been running the country for 33 years and yet the country is not self-reliant. Surely in 33-years we should be in a comfortable position where we have electricity and water 24-hours a day in our cities and the health system functions smoothly. Why are we not there. He messed up the country and he blames everyone but himself, families have been broken up by his dictatorship, it hurt me where at one point in Dali Tambo’s interview he and his family where hugging yet i cannot hug my own family because we in different parts of the world looking for a better life.

    Now he replaced White british influence and replaced it with worse Chinese influence so at the end of the day normal zimbabwean is losing out. We have ample diamond deposits yet we do not see any of the money from the sale of these diamonds which were inititally found by normal people only for mugabe and his cronies to take over after killing a lot of people for it.

    I can write a whole lot but I will need to be interviewed as well and am not a journalist or a politician.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

BayView Classifieds - ads, opportunities, announcements
San Francisco Comcast
Advertisement