by Lynda Carson
According to the Public Defender’s Office, the damning video footage from two separate drug arrests made at the Henry Hotel, a 132-unit, seven-story low-income and homeless resource residential hotel built in 1912, stand in direct contradiction to police reports that were signed by officers under penalty of perjury.
The operations of the narcotics unit accused of using illegal tactics against those being targeted for alleged drug violations have been suspended, prompting an FBI investigation into the activities of the eight-officer undercover plainclothes unit. Presently, a total of six cops are accused of illegal searches and perjury.
Additionally, a third video appears to show the cops forcing someone’s door open on New Year’s Eve at the 69-unit low-income Hotel Royon, managed by the Tenderloin Housing Clinic, revealing that the cops did not even bother to show their badges. The charges filed against the arrested person have since been dropped.
According to Tamara Aparton, spokeswoman for the Public Defender’s Office, there existed a bench warrant for allegedly possessing crack cocaine for the man who was arrested at the Hotel Royon, but there is no record of police checking for the warrant until after he was arrested. It appeared to be an illegal search.
The allegedly illegal busts made recently at the Henry Hotel on Dec. 23 and Jan. 5 involved some of the same officers involved in the allegedly illegal bust made at the Hotel Royon on New Year’s Eve, including Robert Forneris, Arthur Madrid, Raymond Kane and Raul Elias, according to the Public Defender’s Office.
In a press statement, Chief Attorney Matt Gonzales of the San Francisco Public Defender’s Office said the seriousness of the matter could not be overstated. “A free society cannot abide a culture of lawlessness by police,” Gonzales said. “Those officers who lie under oath to magistrates should be prosecuted for their misconduct. They are no better than the criminals they purport to be in pursuit of.”
Bob Dunlap of the Public Defender’s Office added that the videos confirm longstanding suspicions. “For years, our clients have reported tales of police entering their homes without warrants or consent, in direct contravention of the Fourth Amendment and in direct contradiction of the police version of events, and now we have proof both of the police violating core constitutional rights and committing perjury to cover their tracks.”
Lynda Carson may be reached at email@example.com.
Hotel Royan – Dec. 31, 2010
San Francisco Police officers Raymond Kane, Raul Elias, Arthur Madrid and Robert Forneris search a room of the Hotel Royan. The police officers are under investigation, and the case was dropped.
Henry Hotel – Dec. 23, 2010
In this surveillance video, Officers Razzak, Yick, Madrid and Forneris are seen using a master key to barge directly into a room without knocking or obtaining consent. Charges against the man they arrested were dropped by prosecutors.
Henry Hotel – Jan. 5, 2011
In this Jan. 5 video, Officer Richard Yick is seen covering the surveillance camera with his hand while his fellow officers — Razzak, Kane and Elias — approach the room. The officers then demand the female resident open her door. All four officers then storm into the unit. A judge dismissed the case after viewing the video.
Videos reveal police misconduct, perjury
by Tamara Aparton
San Francisco – Surveillance video from the Henry Hotel reveals that San Francisco Police Department narcotics officers falsified police reports in order to justify searching residences without warrants or consent, San Francisco Public Defender Jeff Adachi announced. The damning footage stems from two separate drug arrests on the fifth floor of the Sixth Street single resident occupancy hotel, Dec. 23, 2010 and Jan. 5, 2011.
In both instances, members of the SFPD Narcotics Unit acting on a tip from a confidential informant responded to the Henry Hotel. In the Dec. 23 incident, Officer Arshad Razzak states in a police report that officers knocked on the resident’s door, announced themselves and waited for a response. Hearing none, he wrote, officers slightly opened the door with a master key.
The surveillance video, however, tells a different story. In it, four narcotics officers – Razzak, Yick, Madrid and Forneris – are seen using a master key to barge directly into the room without knocking or obtaining consent.
Charges against the man were dropped by prosecutors this week after the surveillance footage was obtained by the Public Defender’s Office. The man was represented by Deputy Public Defender Anne Irwin.
In the Jan. 5 case, Officer Richard Yick states in a police report that officers were met in the hallway by a woman who voluntarily opened the door to her room. A man who came to the door told officers he was on probation, which police then confirmed with dispatch, Yick wrote, before entering and searching the room. After heroin was found, both the man and woman were arrested.
In the video, however, Yick is seen covering the surveillance camera with his hand while his fellow officers – Razzak, Kane and Elias – approach the room. The officers then demand the female resident open her door. All four officers then storm into the unit.
A judge dismissed the case Feb. 28 after viewing the video, said the woman’s attorney, Deputy Public Defender Tal Klement.
New Henry Hotel footage further implicates SFPD
Newly-released surveillance footage from the Henry Hotel reveals a man was falsely arrested for drug possession by officers currently under federal investigation for perjury and conducting illegal searches.
The footage of the Dec. 2, 2010, arrest was released March 7 by private defense attorney Scott Sugarman during a press conference held at the San Francisco Public Defender’s Office. Sugarman’s case is the fourth video that has surfaced since last week that sharply contradicts police reports signed by officers under penalty of perjury. It is the third case involving the Henry Hotel in SOMA (South of Market neighborhood). The four other incidents in the widening scandal involve Public Defender’s Office cases.
The most recent video involves Southern Station officers Arshad Razzak, Raul Elias and Raymond Kane, who are implicated in previous videos showing illegal searches in residential motels. Also involved are Southern Station Sgt. Samuel Christ and Officer Gregory Buhagiar.
In the video, Sugarman’s client, a 29-year-old man, is seen walking into the Henry Hotel and ascending the stairs wearing a black jacket. Moments later, police using a master key enter the sixth floor room of two women suspected of selling drugs, where the man is a visitor. Officers find a white and gold jacket slung over a chair with drugs in the pocket and no identification.
According to Razzak’s police report, Buhagiar states that he witnessed Sugarman’s client walk into the hotel wearing the same white and gold jacket.
“My client told officers repeatedly that it was not his jacket, that his jacket was right next to him,” Sugarman said. “Police never put his statements in their report, never checked the video and never booked the black jacket into evidence.”
The man, who served three weeks in jail over the incident, was freed when prosecutors dropped the case after a preliminary hearing. Sugarman provided stills from the video that show his client wearing a black jacket.
San Francisco Public Defender Jeff Adachi said the latest incident confirms a disturbing trend in which police officers do not act in pursuit of the truth.
“This was an innocent man who was framed,” Adachi said. “He committed no crime and was arrested simply because he had the misfortune of visiting the Henry Hotel.”
Henry Hotel – Dec. 2, 2010
Jeff Adachi calls for ban on master key abuses; SRO owner says police assaulted him
In a letter to police and prosecutors, San Francisco Public Defender Jeff Adachi today called for a prohibition on officers using hotel master keys to enter tenant residences.
Adachi’s request comes on the heels of the discovery of several surveillance videos showing police using master keys to unlawfully enter residential motel rooms. Officers illegally searched the rooms before fabricating details about the incidents in sworn police reports.
Also raising concerns are two letters obtained by the Public Defender’s Office detailing both recent and long-ago misconduct at residential motels.
A Jan. 23, 2011, letter written by private attorney Michael McCloskey and sent certified mail to SFPD Northern Station Capt. Anne Mannix claims a police officer used physical intimidation to secure a master key from a Tenderloin hotel owner.
McCloskey, who penned the letter on behalf of Luz Hotel owner Virgilio Candari, states that on Jan. 22, 2001, Officer Kevin Byrne visited the Geary Street property and asked for copies of tenants’ identification.
“When Mr. Candari approached the bulletin board which contained the IDs of registered guests, Officer Byrne pushed him away in a violent gesture,” McCloskey wrote. “Mr. Candari is a slender man, not in good health. He was intimidated and frightened by this physical pushing. Officer Byrne then demanded the key to Room 15 and intimidated Mr. Candari into giving him the master key to all rooms.”
“By bullying hotel owners into handing over master keys, police are exposing both the landlords and the city to federal civil rights lawsuits,” he said.
In a second letter, dated March 9, 2011, and addressed to Assistant District Attorney Jerry Coleman, former public defender and current Golden Gate University Law Professor Susan Rutberg details a disturbing 1998 case involving a Turk Street hotel. Police in that case testified they announced themselves and knocked on the door, which was then opened by Rutberg’s client.
The hotel manager, however, testified that the officers, Scott Warnke and Joseph Zamagni, obtained a master key from the front desk. A judge found the police testimony “inherently incredible” and dismissed the case.
Several days later, Rutberg’s client reported being stopped and illegally searched on the street by the same officers, who told him, “You got away with this one, but we’ll get you next time.” Rutberg subsequently filed complaints against the officers with the Office of Citizen Complaints.
Three allegations were sustained, according to Rutberg: two allegations of “Conduct Reflecting Discredit to the Department” for making false statements in the incident report and in a court proceeding and one allegation of “Unwarranted Action” for entering the residence unlawfully.
Adachi said Rutberg’s letter illustrates how long misconduct at residential motels has been tolerated.
Tamara Barak Aparton, communications and policy assistant in the San Francisco Public Defender’s Office, can be reached at Tamara.Aparton@sfgov.org.