Jenny Kang, attorney for political prisoner Jalil Muntaqim (Anthony Bottom), writes: “Attached is a petition to New York Gov. Paterson requesting that Jalil be granted parole or have his sentence commuted. He would very much appreciate your support in signing the petition and sending it to Gov. Paterson. Please feel free to widely distribute the petition.” Jalil, one of the San Francisco 8, made the ultimate sacrifice on July 6, when he pled “no contest” in exchange for the dismissal of all charges against four of his brothers. As a token of our love and appreciation, readers are urged to print this letter, sign it and mail it to Gov. Paterson. – ed.
Honorable David Paterson
Governor of the State of New York
Albany, New York 12224
Re: Application in Behalf of Anthony Bottom 77A4283 for Clemency/Commutation of Sentence to Time Served and/or Parole to Warrant
Governor David Paterson:
I respectfully submit for your review and consideration this Application for Clemency/ Commutation of Sentence to Time Served and/or Parole to Warrant in behalf of Anthony Bottom, 77A4283, a New York State prisoner currently held in San Francisco County Jail on pending charges. The information presented will allow you to see past “the serious nature of the crime” and allow you to assess the blatant reality that Mr. Bottom has achieved rehabilitation within the 38 years he has been incarcerated. We also maintain that he is not a threat to society, and that he would be able to remain at liberty and lead a productive life once given the opportunity.
Mr. Bottom became eligible for parole in 2002 and has appeared before the NYS Division of Parole on three occasions, in 2002, 2004 and 2006. Each of the parole denials was subject to the previous Pataki administration policy to deny discretionary parole for prisoners convicted of a violent offense. Under the Pataki administration, parole decisions had become a game of chance, and Executive Law §259i (2) (c) (a) (1) had been relegated to interpretation subverting the legislative intent of the statute.
Mr. Bottom meets all the requirements to be released on parole pursuant to the guidelines of Executive Law §295i (2) (c) and N.Y.C.R.R. 8000.3 (1) (2) and (3). Furthermore, the U.S. Justice Department Bureau of Statistics has calculated an established means to diminish the probability of persons being released to recommit. Mr. Bottom fits the criteria of these statistics, indicating that people who have been in prison over 10 years, received a college education, participated in rehabilitation and are over 37 years in age, with strong community and family support, have less than a 3 percent rate of recidivism.
I respectfully submit the following for consideration in regards to Anthony Bottom, the person that he is and has become through 36 years of incarceration.
Anthony Bottom is the oldest of four children born to Richmond and Billie Jo Bottom on Oct. 18, 1951, in Oakland, California. He was raised in a middle-class family in San Jose, California. In elementary school, he received a summer scholarship for a high school chemistry program. While in high school, he received a scholarship for a summer San Jose State University math and engineering program. When arrested on Aug. 28, 1971, he was a high school graduate and working as a social worker with California Department of Human Resources program. In the course of growing up, he always had summer jobs, his first paper route job at age 11. While in high school, he became active in the Black Student Union and was a student organizer for the NAACP. After the assassination of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., on April 4, 1968, Anthony Bottom began to look towards the Black Panther Party for leadership. Subsequently, he was recruited into the Party by childhood friends who had become BPP members. Because of his involvement in the Black Panther Party, he became known to the police, the federal government and was subject to COINTELPRO.
Past Criminal History
Mr. Bottom served three years probation for a burglary. On September 19, 1977, Anthony Bottom was parole from San Quentin having served five years for a shoot-out that occurred when arrested in California on August 28, 1971. On March 17, 2004, the Federal Bureau of Prison discharged Mr. Bottom pursuant to an application for nunc pro tunc designation on a 25 year sentence for the robbery of a Fidelity Savings and Loan bank.
Presently, Anthony Bottom is being held in San Francisco County Jail, on an extradition warrant executed on or about April 4, 2007, transferred from Auburn Correctional Facility in New York State. His New York State sentence, and the subject of this Application, is based on a May 1975 commitment of 25 to Life sentence for the murders of New York police officers Waverly M. Jones and Joseph Piagentini on May 21, 1971. He was convicted in a second trial, the first trial having ended in a hung jury favoring an acquittal, and Anthony Bottom continues to maintain his innocence.
It is understood the parole board must evaluate an individual who has been convicted as being guilty of the crimes. However, it is becoming more and more apparent that there are people who are innocent yet have been convicted of crimes. As it pertains to former members of the Black Panther Party who were COINTELPRO targets, many have read headlines of exonerations decades after their convictions. For instance, in California, Geronimo jijaga Pratt spent 27 years incarcerated before exoneration and, in NYS, Dhoruba bin Wahad spent 19 years incarcerated before exoneration. Subsequently he had been part of the investigation in this case. There is a great possibility the man for which this application is presented is truly innocent in this case. The case of Anthony Bottom is one of racial prejudice and government corruption that was present in the Nixon-Hoover era.
At the time of Anthony Bottom’s arrest, former FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover implemented a counterintelligence program designed to target the African-American leaders of the Black Panther Party by infiltrating the movement. This program, known as COINTELPRO, applied tactics such as framing members of the movement for crimes they did not commit to remove them from the community.
On May 26, 1971, five days after the murders of Jones and Piagentini, Hoover was summoned to the White House for a confidential meeting with President Richard Nixon and Domestic Affairs Advisor John Erlichman to discuss the unsolved case. This meeting targeted the Black Panther Party as suspects in the murder of the two police officers. Appeals and post conviction challenges on this case have been filed and thus far have been unsuccessful.
Judith M. Rosen, Esq., who represented Anthony Bottom at an evidentiary hearing in 1992, reported: “At the evidentiary hearing before Judge Lasker in 1992, which I participated in, it was determined the Chief of Ballistics of New York City Police Department had committed a grave error as to the ballistics evidence that was the foundation of Mr. Bottom’s conviction. Although this was ruled harmless error, I believe that decision was based more on political than legal grounds.”
Prior to the July 30, 2004, NYS parole hearing, the son of the slain police officer Waverly M. Jones presented a victim impact statement to Richard Dennison, former Chairman of the NYS Board of Parole. In the formal interview with Richard Dennison, Waverly Jones Jr. stated he did not believe Anthony Bottom and co-defendant Herman Bell were guilty of the murders and, if they were, that he and his family had forgiven them and are advocating for their release on parole. The July 2004 parole board ignored the victim impact statement of Waverly Jones Jr., which was taken on appeal to the NYS Appellant Court for the Third Department. Although the Third Department, on July 1, 2006, did not reverse the parole denial, the Court did admonish the NYS Division of Parole for its failure to consider the victim impact statement.
Victim Impact Statement and NYS Appellant Court Ruling
As directed by NYS Executive Law §259(i), a factor that must be considered when evaluating an individual for discretionary parole release is the victim impact statement. In this case, the victim impact statement was given in favor of the release of Anthony Bottom. In the 2004 parole hearing, Mr. Waverly Jones Jr. stated in pertinent parts:
“Me, personally, have forgiven these men for the positions that they took back then. I personally feel that when you think of the ‘60s you think of a very turbulent time, not only in New York but throughout the country, and we know historically black people of course have been oppressed … I do not have hatred or revenge or anything for any of those individuals. I sincerely feel that I don’t particularly see them as a danger. I don’t see them as someone that’s going to come out of prison and commit violent crimes or anything of that nature.”
The transcript continues:
“Let me ask you this question, sir: Will these gentlemen continually be sent to parole every two years and continually be denied because of the crime that they committed? It sounds like why even go before the Parole Board? It sounds like it’s humiliating to go before the Parole Board after so many years demonstrating your viability to society and then that be completely disregarded if the type of crime you committed in the eyes of the Parole Board is too atrocious to be released, because the nature of the crime is never going to change.
“Jones: It’s almost like are they going to be every two years at the mercy of the whim of the members of the Board if they feel, OK, you served enough time? Is that the way they are going to deal with this? Or should it be that there would be so much overwhelming outside support from underneath that they are forced to let them go because there is so much support for this release that to deny him would be like a terrible message to society if there’s so much support in favor of him being released? What will it take for the Parole Board to be moved to release them if the nature of the crime is never going to change?
“Dennison: I really can’t speak about them. I can speak about Mr. Bottom, because every case is a little bit different … I really can only speak about Mr. Bottom. He has been in prison a long time.
“Jones: I feel that Herman Bell and Anthony Bottom were both victims as well of a much larger scheme which got them incarcerated to this day, and I feel that their sentence was 25-to-life, and to me they have shown great resilience in prison, that their mind is still intact, that their spirit is still eager to do good, and I just pray that the Parole Board will look at the context and the time and send a message to me of healing. Both black and white need to heal from that moment in history because it’s still affecting us today, injustices that both suffered. We are the ones dealing with that today, and I feel that men like him who are in that time period and they may have did certain things in their life would send a message to me of forgiveness and healing and time to I say amend that period in history so that we can both enjoy good perpetuity on both sides.
“I think that keeping them in prison is only strengthening resentment among grassroots individuals and is producing a greater passion in them to pick up a weapon, and I believe that keeping them prison in their eyes is almost like there is no justice, if you will. I just don’t think that’s a good message to send out, and that’s why I requested to meet with the NYS Parole Board.”
In 2004, with this statement ignored, Anthony Bottom was denied parole. An appeal proceeded, but the transcript of the victim impact statement was not available at the time of the submission of the Article 7800 in the Supreme Court in Albany. However, it was made available at the time of the appeal to the NYS Appellant Court for the Third Department.
In The Matter of Bottom vs. The NYS Board of Parole, Index No. 98942 (3rd Dept., July 1, 2006), responding to reading the victim impact statement, the Court held:
“Although the adult son of the slain police officer appeared at a victim impact meeting concerning petitioner and spoke at length in favor of his release, respondent’s subsequent decision makes no mention of that statement and neither a transcript of the victim impact statement nor a report thereon appears in the administrative record. In fact, respondent affirmatively cited the negative impact of petitioner’s actions upon the victim’s families as one justification for denying him parole … Whereas here it is provided with a victim impact statement which advocates for the release of the prospective parolee, explicit reference to such an exceptional submission would facilitate intelligent appellate review.”
In the Aug. 1, 2006, NYS parole hearing, again, the Waverly Jones Jr. victim impact statement was ignored, even though Anthony Bottom raised the issue. The parole panel conducting the hearing refused to discuss the victim impact statement, only inquiring as to how Anthony Bottom received a copy of the Waverly Jones Jr. victim impact statement. Discretionary release on parole was summarily denied, employing the same reasons for denial as had been applied in the two previous parole hearings of 2002 and 2004.
The NYS Appellant Division for the Third Department held the victim impact statement advocating for release must be seriously considered by the Parole Board or the decision will be reviewed by the Court. Unfortunately, as will be shown below, the Court will not review the Parole Board’s failure to consider the positive victim impact statement.
Extraordinary Circumstances for Clemency/Commutation of Sentence
On or about April 4, 2007, Anthony Bottom was transferred from Auburn Correctional Facility pursuant to an extradition warrant to San Francisco charged in a felony complaint (not a Grand Jury indictment) with seven other named defendants, for conspiracy and murder of a San Francisco police officer on Aug. 29, 1971. Consequently, because Mr. Bottom is not in NYS, the appeal of the Aug. 1, 2006, parole denial has been deemed moot by the NYS Supreme Court of Albany County. Furthermore, according to Mr. Terrance X. Tracy, Counsel of NYS Division of Parole, future parole hearings will not be conducted until he is returned to NYS.
While the San Francisco felony complaint is based on a 38-year-old crime, the matter was not expected to proceed to trial for at least one year. Therefore, Anthony Bottom could not be in New York State for the scheduled July 2008 parole hearing, and there were no arrangements to hold the hearing by teleconference. In effect, Mr. Bottom has for two years been made ineligible for parole.
It must be noted the San Francisco felony complaint as written is subject to many defense challenges. As a result of several pre-trial motion hearings, the substance of the complaint has been found to be inconsistent with the allegations proclaimed in the original extradition warrant. For instance, the prosecution now concedes there are no DNA matches to any of the defendants. The prosecution does not have the alleged murder weapon (the shotgun has been lost) and the latent fingerprint examination on a cigarette lighter found at the scene has proved inconclusive, with four previous exams – two by the FBI and two by San Francisco forensic experts – not matching any of the defendants. While DNA and another latent print were found on the cigarette lighter, none belonged to any of the defendants.
The offenses charged in the San Francisco felony complaint allegedly happened on Aug. 29, 1971, but Anthony Bottom was arrested and in San Francisco County Jail on Aug. 28, 1971, therefore not a direct participant in the alleged crime. While six of the eight defendants named in the San Francisco felony complaint were released on bail, the charge of conspiracy was dropped against five of the defendants. For one of them, conspiracy was his only charge and he has been dismissed from the entire case. Given the fact that six of the eight defendants named in the San Francisco felony complaint have been released on bail, Mr. Anthony Bottom had a liberty interest in having his NYS sentence commuted to time served and/or parole to the warrant.
Then on July 6, 2009, on the day the preliminary hearing was to begin, the California prosecutor offered a plea agreement of no contest to conspiracy to commit voluntary manslaughter, sentence to three years probation, one year of jail time credited to time served, the entire sentence to run concurrent with the New York State sentence. It was further offered that if Mr. Bottom accepted the plea agreement, four other defendants would be dismissed from the case for insufficient evidence. After 27 months in solitary confinement on 23-hour lockdown in San Francisco County Jail, Mr. Bottom, with no admission of guilt, pled no contest.
NYS Institutional Involvement
As reported at Mr. Bottom’s previous application for parole, the highlights of his achievements while incarcerated include:
In 1986, Anthony drafted a legislative bill for New York State prisoners to obtain good time off their sentence. The bill was submitted and introduced into the New York State Assembly Committee on Corrections by former Assemblyman Arthur O. Eve.
In 1994, while incarcerated at Shawangunk Correctional Facility, Anthony established the first Men’s Council in a United States prison. His efforts were featured on television in Japan and written about in the New York Times. During this period, he also graduated from SUNY – New Paltz with a B.S. in Psychology and a B.A. in Sociology. Instead of resting on his success, he taught African Studies to a group of prisoners.
On two occasions, he received commendations from prison officials for quelling potential prison riots, one in the mess hall at Great Meadow Correctional Facility and another time in the auditorium at Greenhaven Correctional Facility.
From 1996 to 1999, Anthony was the office manager of the prison computer lab at Eastern Correctional Facility. His duties consisted of teaching prisoners keyboarding skills and how to use computer software programs. Despite his busy schedule, he found the time to raise money from inmate accounts to support the charitable Children’s Funds.
In 1999, in Auburn Correctional Facility, Anthony established sociology, poetry and legal research and discussion classes under the auspices of the Lifers’ Committee that he chaired.
Anthony co-sponsored the Victory Gardens Project, a program in which farmers in Maine grew tons of fresh produce for distribution to poor urban communities in New York, New Jersey and Boston, Massachusetts. In the four years of its existence, the project distributed nearly 10,000 pounds of fresh produce in urban centers.
In response to the tragedy of Sept. 11, 2001, while in Auburn Correctional Facility, Anthony proposed raising funds from inmates to donate to the American Red Cross. Former Deputy Superintendent of Programs R. Nelson acknowledged Anthony’s efforts in a memorandum.
While in Auburn Correctional Facility he worked as a Pre-GED Teacher’s Assistant, earned a vocational certificate for Architectural Drafting and Anthony has proposed and gained approval for a Life Skills Program for inmates.
Anthony is a published poet and essayist; his writings are found in several University sponsored books of compilations of prison writers. He has also written an unpublished novel and teleplay.
Parole Release Plans
In the event that Anthony Bottom’s Application for Clemency/ Commutation of Sentence is approved and he is released on bail pending the resolution of present charges, he would live in either Syracuse, New York, or Austell, Georgia. In Syracuse, he would apply to the Master’s program at Maxwell School, Syracuse University, to obtain a degree in Public Administration and a certificate in Health Services Management. In Austell, Georgia, he has an offer of employment in the construction field and a home that is to be provided by his mother.
Anthony Bottom has a 36-year-old daughter, two grandchildren and one great grandchild. Over the decades of imprisonment, he has maintained a strong family relationship although they reside in California and Georgia. Throughout his years of imprisonment, there have been continuous family visits when they were able, including family trailer visits. As an example, in the November 2000 issue of Essence Magazine, Anthony Bottom, his daughter and granddaughter were featured in an article titled “Daddy Says,” discussing father and daughter relationships. Mr. Bottom will continue to be involved in community service, particularly in regards to AIDS education. He once initiated a campaign to provide school supplies to AIDS orphans in Africa.
It should be noted that since his last parole appearance Mr. Bottom has obtained certificates of appreciation in the field of drafting. He hopes to use this training in construction work. In addition, he has participated in the aggression resolution-training program (ART), complimenting the certificates he already received in aggression management, substance abuse and behavior therapeutics. It should also be noted that Mr. Bottom has not received any serious misbehavior reports since his last parole board appearance. It is my sincere hope that you will see past the political ramifications in this case, as Mr. Bottom is deserving commutation of sentence to time served and/or parole to the warrant.
In my opinion, the time is now to correct the wrongs that have been done to Anthony Bottom by the administration of this government as a result of COINTELPRO activities. Although convicted at trial, he has been robbed of his life solely because of his political beliefs and his involvement in the Black Panther Party.
Mr. Bottom has maintained his innocence for decades throughout his incarceration but has accepted the circumstances and participated in the rehabilitation that was provided him by the NYS Department of Corrections. He has exceeded the guidelines depicted in NYS Executive Law for parole release considerations. Mr. Bottom has been an asset and role model to many of the inmates. He has worked extensively throughout his incarceration to improve himself, to establish a peaceful environment in his otherwise chaotic environment, and to assist others in their rehabilitation. Mr. Bottom deserves his freedom and a chance to be an asset to his community from outside the walls of prisons.
in behalf of Anthony Bottom, 77A4283