Hillary Clinton is no friend of Black empowerment


by Musa al-Gharbi

As an African American, I have struggled to understand why so many of my Black brothers and sisters seem to prefer Hillary Clinton over Bernie Sanders.

While Hillary Clinton tries to recast herself as a champion of Black empowerment, even a child can sense the hypocrisy behind the smile.
While Hillary Clinton tries to recast herself as a champion of Black empowerment, even a child can sense the hypocrisy behind the smile.

Some have argued that Black people are terrified at the prospect of a Trump presidency, and so they rally around Clinton under the belief that she is more electable in the November general contest. However, looking at the election results so far, it seems clear that Bernie Sanders actually stands the best chance of prevailing over Trump, while Hillary would likely lose.

Then there’s the notion that Hillary Clinton is somehow preserving Barack Obama’s legacy: Just a few short months ago she was going out of her way to distance herself from the Obama administration because she believed it was politically expedient to do so. Now, under threat from Sanders’ insurgency, she is cynically trying to sell herself as Obama’s right hand. But of course, the moment she locks down the nomination, she’ll go back to drawing contrasts – the Clintons have always been leaders at “vote capturing.”

But perhaps the most disturbing of all is the insinuation that Hillary Clinton has some kind of proud and storied legacy in the service of Black empowerment. She doesn’t. Consider the comparative records of Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders:

The Chicago years

While attending the University of Chicago, Sanders served as a chapter chairman for the Congress for Racial Equality. In this capacity, he worked to end segregation in schools and housing – activities for which he was arrested.

What was Hillary Clinton doing while Sanders was organizing sit-ins and demonstrations? Well, she was also living in Chicago at the time, but she was working for the other team: In 1963-4, Clinton was a volunteer and supporter for the campaign of Barry Goldwater.

For those who don’t know, Goldwater’s claim to fame is that he was the first Republican to win the Deep South since Reconstruction. He achieved this feat by vowing to undermine enforcement of the Civil Rights Act and to prevent further erosion of white privilege.

In 1963, Bernie Sanders took part in the historic March on Washington with Dr. King. In 1964, Hillary Clinton supported Barry Goldwater, a Republican right-winger almost as infamous as Trump, for president.
In 1963, Bernie Sanders took part in the historic March on Washington with Dr. King. In 1964, Hillary Clinton supported Barry Goldwater, a Republican right-winger almost as infamous as Trump, for president.

His campaign was so disgusting that many Republican leaders, such as George Romney and John Rockefeller, refused to endorse his candidacy even after he won his party’s nomination. A good deal of the Republican electorate, who had traditionally championed civil rights and civil liberties, also refused to support him.

As a result, those aforementioned Deep South states were literally the only contests he won other than his home state of Arizona in one of the most dramatic landslide losses in U.S. presidential history. Yet, this is the man who inspired Hillary Clinton to get into politics. And she was campaigning for him while Bernie was campaigning for desegregation.

The trend continues: In 1984 and ‘88, Bernie Sanders endorsed and supported Jesse Jackson’s bids for the White House, which would have made him America’s first African-American president. Rather than endorsing this movement, Bill Clinton infamously sought to elevate himself among white Southern and Rust-Belt voters at the expense of Mr. Jackson and his Rainbow Coalition.

Of course, it’d be easy to write this off – after all, it was a long time ago. However, the Clintons’ tenure in the White House doesn’t look so great in hindsight either:

The Clinton administration(s)

Bill Clinton’s deregulation of banks and Wall Street helped bring about the 2008 financial collapse that profoundly and disproportionately obliterated Black wealth. In the wake of this disaster, and despite the banks’ long and sordid history of discrimination and predatory practices against people of color, Hillary Clinton continues to defend the institutions responsible – and is richly rewarded for doing so.

Bill Clinton’s welfare reform further contributed to extreme poverty – particularly for African Americans and other communities of color. While Bernie strongly resisted these measures, Hillary staunchly advocated for them – referring to people on welfare as “deadbeats” who were largely responsible for their own continued poverty.

And then, of course, there are the Clinton-era “tough on crime” measures, which Hillary Clinton actively lobbied for. While Sanders ultimately voted for the bill for the sake of its assault rifle ban and domestic violence protections, he first took to the Senate floor to passionately denounce the draconian sentencing provisions contained therein, which he aptly predicted would be exercised primarily against America’s poor, largely people of color. In contrast, Hillary Clinton referred to the criminalized as animals, describing them as “super-predators” who have to be “brought to heel.”

More Americans were incarcerated under Bill Clinton than any previous president – almost all of them poor people, overwhelmingly Black and Brown. Yet as late as 2008, despite the by-then obvious effects of these policies on communities of color, Clinton stood by this record proudly and actually mocked Barack Obama’s opposition to mandatory minimum sentences.

Later in that same cycle, it would be Clinton supporters who first began circulating rumors that Barack Obama was not born in the United States and might be a secret Muslim – launching the “birther” movement. Not only did Clinton fail to denounce these claims from her supporters – then later hypocritically bash Donald Trump for doing the same – her campaign actively attempted to capitalize on this paranoia, dog-whistling that Hillary was “born in the middle of America to the middle class in the middle of the last century” and bragging about the edge she held over Obama among non-college attending white Americans.

Little has changed

Then again, 2008 was eight years ago, right? What about today?

Consider that one of the people currently attempting to slime Bernie Sanders on Clinton’s behalf is her long-time friend and ally, David Brock, who infamously led the hatchet job against law professor Anita Hill when she accused Supreme Court nominee Clarence Thomas of sexual harassment. For Hillary Clinton to sell herself as a champion of women and African Americans while closely associating herself with someone like Brock is deeply unsettling … much like Clinton taking foreign policy and national security guidance from the same consulting firm that formulates strategy for Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio.

In a recent debate, Clinton reiterated confederate narratives about the origins of America’s racial dynamics. In the aftermath of Dylann Roof’s massacre at Emannuel AME in Charleston, she went to a predominantly Black church in Ferguson, Missouri – the site of the first Black Lives Matter uprisings following the death of Michael Brown – and went out of her way to emphasize that “All Lives Matter.”

One could go on and on. These are not instances of occasional misspeaking or malformed policies – instead, a consistent pattern of words and actions persisting over decades. This is not to suggest Hillary Clinton is racist, at least not any more than most white people, but the idea that she is or ever has been a stalwart advocate for Black empowerment is absolutely ludicrous.

A generational divide?

Although Black people do vote with more cohesiveness than most other groups, we are not a monolith. And the narrative that people of color unanimously back Clinton over Sanders is misleading at best:

While much of the “old guard” of African American politicians has rallied around Hillary Clinton, newer leaders – like Rep. Keith Ellison and contemporary Black revolutionaries like Cornel West and Ta-Nehisi Coates – have aligned themselves with Bernie Sanders in the conviction that his policies and his approach stand the best chance of meaningfully redressing social inequality. Still others, such as Black Lives Matter Chicago co-founder Aislinn Pulley, are demanding substantive action over platitudes or token reforms and are increasingly refusing to be part of the DNC farce at all.

This bodes ill for Clinton: The longer this race goes on, and the more Black voters examine the comparative records, platforms and prospects of Clinton v. Sanders, the more likely it is that the former’s cynical identity politics campaign will once again implode, as it did in 2008.

Hillary’s record on civil rights is indeed extensive, albeit inconsistent and often ignoble. By contrast, Bernie has a long, proud, consistent record on fighting inequality – often far ahead of the Democratic Party in this regard – and always far, far ahead of Hillary Clinton.

Musa al-Gharbi is a political philosopher affiliated with the Southwest Initiative for the Study of Middle East Conflict (SISMEC). Readers can connect to his work and social media via his website, www.fiatsophia.org, where this story first appeared. It was republished by Salon.


  1. As a Senior African American, I applaud you and you are right on target. I am still smarting from the Bill Clinton remark during the 2008 campaign that "Obama would be carrying his bags in past years" It grieves me to see my generation continue to support the Democrat Party/Clintons unanimously. With people like you and Nina Turner backing "Bernie" I rest my case. You are thankfully the voice we need for our future.

  2. Do you struggle playing poker successfully? Are you unsure of your style, or the best style? Well these advanced poker strategy tips will help you. <a href="http://www.fashion101.ushttp://www.fashion101.us<br />
    In the last few months there have been many Health Care Reform rules and regulations updated by the Health and Human Services Department. But despite all the media coverage of these events, many people still hold fast to certain myths surrounding ObamaCare. We'll uncover and dislodge these clinging myths by pushing them off the ledge of reality, where they don't belong. <a href="http://www.101health.ushttp://www.101health.us<br />
    Scientific works in the theories of finances and credit, according to the specification of the research object, are characterized to be many-sided and many-leveled. The definition of totality of the economical relations formed in the process of formation, distribution and usage of finances, as money sources is widely spread. For example, in "the general theory of finances" there are two definitions of finances: <a href="http://www.smallfinance.ushttp://www.smallfinance.us<br />
    At one time people were very nervous about purchasing any type of jewelry online. This was especially true with buying diamonds online, now you can buy with more confidence than ever before. This is mainly due to the fact that any purchase made with a credit card has added protection built into it. <a href="http://www.onlinebuy.ushttp://www.onlinebuy.us<br />
    A home improvement store is a place where you can buy home appliances, lumber, tools, lawn mowers, paint, brushes and everything that you need for your latest project. You may be used to walking into a traditional warehouse, walking around until your feet are tired, asking for help and still leaving without all of the items that you need. Why not try something different? <a href="http://www.homeimprovementideas.ushttp://www.homeimprovementideas.us<br />
    Luxury travelers make different plans compared to the average traveler. They book different hotels and head to different destinations. Are you a luxury traveler? <a href="http://www.mytravelguide.ushttp://www.mytravelguide.us<br />
    Choosing the right decorating style is important to making your home feel like your own. Learn how to choose the best style for your home and preferences and to create a home with modern style, contemporary style, traditional style, country style, or retro style. <a href="http://www.fashionadvice.ushttp://www.fashionadvice.us<br />
    Health insurance has proven itself of great help and financial aid in certain cases when events turn out unexpectedly. In times when you are ill and when your health is in grave jeopardy and when finances seem to be incapable to sustain for your care, health insurance is here to the rescue. A good health insurance plan will definitely make things better for you. <a href="http://www.besthealth.ushttp://www.besthealth.us<br />
    Many of us never think about the universal laws that govern our life every single day. However, they are continually operating behind the scene, creating the experience in your life. Understanding how they work and how to use them in a positive way can make a huge difference in your life. <a href="http://www.aboutlaw.ushttp://www.aboutlaw.us<br />
    Online Shopping is today the most convenient and exciting way of shopping. It caters to every income group and therefore has a wide customer base. It allows customers to buy goods and services from sellers or merchants using the internet. Many people find this the most relaxed form of shopping, more so from the convenience of their home. <a href="http://www.proshopper.ushttp://www.proshopper.us<br />

  3. The issue of in-laws is one which many wives wish did not exist in marriage. This is because it is the bane of many ailing marriages. Many daughters-in-law tend to dislike their mothers-in-law and very few daughters-in-law have ever had any thing good to say about a mother-in-law. <a href="http://www.lawadvice.us” target=”_blank”>www.lawadvice.us
    If you want an excellent shopping center experience, you may do well to go off the beaten track. When you take yourself away from the crowds and into smaller local settings, you can find a lot of excitement and offerings that you would never see in a large generic shopping mall setting. <a href="http://www.shoppingblog.us” target=”_blank”>www.shoppingblog.us
    When it comes to college living, the nonprofit student housing development option is often overlooked. However, there are many benefits to going this route, starting with the development's central focus: the young college scholar. <a href="http://www.housedevelopment.us” target=”_blank”>www.housedevelopment.us
    One of the growing sectors in the travel industry is the group tour sector. There are thousands of organisations providing group tours in almost every country. How does one find the group tour that suits? Here are a few tips. <a href="http://www.grouptour.us” target=”_blank”>www.grouptour.us
    1. Amazon – Amazon, based in the United States and one of the largest online retailers in the world, offers, other than various other categories such as books, electronics, home decor, bags and luggage, jewellery, etc., clothing and accessories to its customers. <a href="http://www.fashionkeeper.us” target=”_blank”>www.fashionkeeper.us
    The provision of health sanitation is a key development intervention – without it, ill health dominates a life without dignity. Simply having access to sanitation increases health, well-being and economic productivity. Inadequate sanitation impacts individuals, households, communities and countries. <a href="http://www.tophealth.us” target=”_blank”>www.tophealth.us
    Deepak Chopra's book, "The 7 Spiritual Laws of Success" illustrates seven laws which can be applied easily to learning how to run a successful business online. It's with great pleasure that I bring you the 7 Spiritual Laws of Success and how I've been able to apply them to learning how to market online… <a href="http://www.lawcafe.us” target=”_blank”>www.lawcafe.us
    Every now and then, you find the best shopping mall just off a main road that surprises you with its extensive yet exciting ambiance. This has become the perfect haven for people who love to shop, eat, relax or simply unwind. With over hundred stalls and shops, almost anything and everything is for sale. <a href="http://www.shoppingguru.us” target=”_blank”>www.shoppingguru.us
    It might surprise you how a few home improvement tips can make a huge difference to your whole project of home improvement. Whether it is simply to renovate your kitchen or to entirely change the look of your study room, the following tips will definitely help you with new and better ideas which you wouldn't have thought of. <a href="http://www.improveyourhomes.us” target=”_blank”>www.improveyourhomes.us
    Travelling with friends, family, and loved ones can be great, but the benefits of social travel are very different from the benefits of travelling alone. With the right mindset, you'll see how travelling alone is not only an incredible life experience- it's often a necessary life experience. <a href="http://www.drtravel.us” target=”_blank”>www.drtravel.us

Leave a Reply