Support SF BayView
Donate or Subscribe to SF Bay View
Follow Us Twitter Facebook

Blacks doubt Mississippi hanging death is suicide

January 5, 2011

by Jesse Muhammad – The idea of a so-called post-racial America was widely discussed, debated and even seen as an achievement by some with Barack Obama’s inauguration as president of the United States.

National NAACP President Ben Jealous said, “In the year 2010, people shouldn’t have to worry about being lynched,” after Frederick Jermaine Carter, 26, was found hanging from a 12-foot-high branch of an oak tree in the upscale white neighborhood of North Greenwood, Miss.
For Blacks in Greenwood, Mississippi, the notion that America has gotten beyond race isn’t popular today. Many are angry over the recent mysterious hanging death of Frederick Jermaine Carter.

“This is 2010 and we still have Black people hanging from trees? They’re saying he hung himself but I have doubt in my mind that he actually did that. That wasn’t his character. This wasn’t a suicide; this was a homicide,” said Sunflower, Miss., Mayor Michael Pembleton Jr. to The Final Call.

The body of Mr. Carter, 26, was found Dec. 3 hanging from an oak tree in the predominately White North Greenwood area of Leflore County. The young man lived in neighboring Sunflower County, several miles away.

Mr. Carter’s stepfather told law enforcement that he was working in the area with his stepson when Mr. Carter wandered off.

County Sheriff Ricky Banks reportedly told the media the young man had a “mental condition and a history of wandering off.” He also publicly stated that he saw no signs at the scene pointing towards it being a crime or murder.

“This is 2010 and we still have Black people hanging from trees? … This wasn’t a suicide.”

Mr. Banks said evidence shows Mr. Carter dragged an old frame of a nearby table, leaned it against the trunk of the tree and commenced to tying himself to the tree limb.

“The frame probably broke, possibly because Carter kicked it out from under himself,” Mr. Banks told reporters.

The preliminary autopsy results by the Leflore County Coroner’s Office declared it a suicide.

The deceased man’s family and community leaders don’t accept the official explanations and are calling for further investigation.

“Because there has been no investigation on the part of the local officials into this as a crime, we’re calling on the federal government to conduct an independent investigation. We want the U.S. Justice department to look into this,” attorney Valerie Hicks Powe told The Final Call in a phone interview on Dec. 13.

Ms. Powe, who is based in Birmingham, Ala., is the spokesperson for the victim’s family. “A crime scene was never established. They never roped the scene off and this has not been treated as a crime. There is no reason to believe that he would commit suicide. We appreciate attention being brought to this because we need an outcry from the people,” she said.

One of the most gruesome lynchings in U.S history took place in Money, Miss., approximately 10 miles north of Greenwood. In August 1955, 14-year-old Emmett Till was beaten, shot in the head, his eyes gouged out, and thrown into the Tallahatchie River with a cotton gin fan tied around his neck with barbed wire after accusations he whistled at a White woman. Two White males were acquitted in the case while the boy’s mother held an open casket funeral that made national headlines. It was also a watershed moment for the civil rights movement as the horror of Southern violence and brutality was put before the world.

Unanswered questions and appeals for outside help

Loved ones and relatives want answers to questions about the death of Mr. Carter and the story thus far does not ring true, they say. “He didn’t have a mental problem. His problem was he tended to not defend himself against others in conflict, but he wouldn’t kill himself. The family is requesting a second autopsy and want to also have an autopsy done by someone out of the state of Mississippi,” says Mr. Pembleton, who is also a cousin of the victim.

State Sen. David Jordan was able to obtain gruesome photos of Mr. Carter’s body hanging from the tree. He went to the scene himself and is also skeptical of what is being reported.

“There are a lot of unanswered questions. He reportedly had rope in his pocket but didn’t have anything to cut it with? Why wasn’t the scene of the crime blocked off? That tree limb is nearly 12 feet high. I’m 6-2 and I can’t see how I could maneuver to do that, so how could a boy his height hang himself like that?” asks Mr. Jordan, who is also a Greenwood city councilman.

Mr. Jordan met with the victim’s mother, Brenda Carter, when he obtained the photos of her son. “She told me her son loved life too much to take his life. We want another autopsy now,” he said.

“There are a lot of unanswered questions … Why wasn’t the scene of the crime blocked off?”

Wendol Lee, president of the Memphis-based Operation Help Civil Rights Group, said some 300 residents petitioned his group to get involved because of “paranoia related to the history of lynching.”

“The area where he was found hanging is an area that Black people do not go into, according to what residents have told us. Blacks get harassed and stopped by the police in that area, so why would this young man go way over there to kill himself? We believe someone took him over there and killed him,” said Mr. Lee, who also works with the National Action Network.

Mr. Lee’s group has been on the ground interviewing residents, who he says also do not believe Mr. Carter would take his own life. “He was a good young man who was seen always helping the children,” he added.

On Dec. 9, Mr. Lee’s group led a press conference with the family in Greenwood to express dissatisfaction with the investigation and issue his group’s call for a national federal probe.

“We know Whites that are in power in Mississippi have never shown favor to Blacks. We’re reaching out to Attorney General Eric Holder to order an investigation on the federal level because we’re getting conflicting statements from the police,” said Mr. Lee.

Following the press conference, Mr. Lee said they went back to the scene and found what could possibly be “an extra set of footprints. We’re leaning towards that this was a killing because everyone we talked to has never seen Frederick in that area before until his body was found,” he noted.

“How did he (Mr. Carter) get out there so far? That’s a serious question. I’m concerned about the way the knot was tied around his neck. That’s a very particular type of knot that you don’t see Black people walking around with,” said Larry Muhammad, Nation of Islam representative in Greenville, Miss.

A major protest in Greenwood may be brewing, according to Mr. Lee. “This is not the old days. You can’t just hang Black people today and think nothing is going to happen. If need be, we’re going to invite Al Sharpton to get involved. We’re going to get ready to shake up this town!” vowed Mr. Lee.

Leflore County Supervisor Preston Ratliff is questioning the reported suicide as well. “I have not made many public statements because I’m still waiting for more information but I do think it is strange that he would hang himself in such a remote area. The mere fact that a Black man is found hanging in a White neighborhood is disturbing based on the history of the Delta,” he said.

According to Mr. Ratliff, Leflore County is approximately 65 percent Black and 35 percent White in population. He doesn’t deny the racial problems in his area but points out that it’s not as bad as it used to be.

“It’s better than people think, but we still have a long way to go. I simply want the truth to come out in this hanging. If it is proven that this is the result of foul play, then those who are responsible need to be found,” said Mr. Ratliff.

“What attracted my attention was that it took place in this big field in a White community. I went to the scene and I didn’t see any evidence that a struggle took place. The first autopsy says suicide but nobody believes that is the case,” said Dr. Eddie Carthan, who heads Good Samaritan Ecumenical Church in Tchula, Miss.

“I’m striving to look at this objectively. Right now we’re not sure and we’re still investigating,” he said.

“There is no sign that we could find whatsoever that anyone else was involved. I haven’t seen anything to change my mind, and I’m looking really hard,” said Sheriff Banks to the media.

Blacks in the area don’t see it the same way. “We can’t have a young Black man hanging and we just go back to business as usual. We can’t sit by and let this go (on). People want stuff like this to get swept under the rug,” countered Mr. Jordan.

Jesse Muhammad, a staff writer for the Final Call newspaper, is known for his coverage of the Jena 6 and Hurricane Katrina survivors, and an award-winning blogger. Email him at and visit Brother Jesse Blog at

10 thoughts on “Blacks doubt Mississippi hanging death is suicide

  1. Val

    They need to also check for fingerprints to make sure their wasn’t any foul play. It’s sad that we still live in times where people are still prejudice. We all have to live in this country together and have been for centuries. It is not going to change. This is just cruel and un called for. I hope who ever is responsible for this young man death will be found and pay his/her debt to society…

  2. Robin Robinson

    It's not hard to believe the young man was murdered. What I don't understand about the story is….Who is AL Sharpton! Sharpton has proven he is nothing more than a race baiter. He only gets involved in issues to further his own Agenda. Sharpton, Jesse, Cornell West as well as other selected blacks have proven their allegiance is to the Dollar and self preservation. We have to turn to THE MOST HIGH! THE MOST HIGH is our hope, HE is the only ONE who can turn back the curse we are under. And HE will punish the guilty.

    1. Lisa

      Al Sharpton is awesome!! Who are you Mr. Racist! People act like racism doesn't exist in America but it does and you are proof!

  3. Karima Cooper

    GOD help us!!! This is crazy!!!! I don't blame his parents. I would not trust anyone in that town to clarify the cause of death either. They are doing the right thing by bringing in the Federal Government to investigate. If it was a murder judgement day is soon to come. Nothing goes !!!

  4. Rere Sponse

    To: Robin R.. Yes, we call on our Lord for help. Yet, it is better not to call out the names of the other trail blazers especially if YOU or I am not on the scene of the incident doing something about It. Easy to just take it somethings. Ultimately God already has the murderers plainly..No one escapes his EYES..Thanks you Lord

  5. Minister Emmanuel

    What can we do to stop this kind of thing from continuing?
    I know the Lord cares & will help but God works to man through man.
    We MUST do something!!!
    If the man was mentally ill why would he hang himself on a tree?
    Did he carried a rope around in his pocket for just an occasion?
    County Sheriff Ricky Banks & his office needs to be hung for trying to get the American public to believe such a bald faced lie.
    Minister Emmanuel

  6. Brenda

    This is an outrage and the civil activist, and people against prejudice should banned together and look further into this criminal investigation. As a mother, my heart go out to you for the injustice that has occurred. My the truth come out and bring the people responsible for such a haneious act comes to justice in such a racial country.

  7. Keith Warren

    There is also a case of a young black man by the name if Keith Warren who was found strung up on a tree in 1986. This July will mark the 25th anniversary of his death. there is insurmountable evidence that he was put there on the tree and law enforcement let someone get away with murder. His family is still fighting for justice and local law enforcement is continuing to turn a blind eye.

  8. Percy Streets

    Turning to God for any reason in regard to this hanging is a total waste of time. It is time for us black people to get up off our knees praying to a God who doesn't exist! You'll never find out who hanged this young man by relying on God to help in the capture of the guilty parties. The ones who hanged him don't believe
    God will expose them, simply because they don't believe in Him. WAKE UP!


Leave a Reply

BayView Classifieds - ads, opportunities, announcements