Support SF BayView
Donate or Subscribe to SF Bay View
Follow Us Twitter Facebook

A police lynching happens every 36 hours

July 18, 2012

by Dr. David J. Leonard

Throughout the early part of the 20th century, African-American activists fought to thwart the systemic scourge of lynching. Faced with a silent and complicit populace, particularly the media and political establishment, African Americans forced the nation to bear witness to the depravity of American racism.

Enraged by a spate of police murders, New Orleanians protest on March 31, 2012.
Between 1882 and 1968, close to 5,000 lynchings – 73 percent of the victims were Black – took place on American soil, and that is of course an estimate that does not account for the countless unknown souls who lost their lives at the hands of white supremacy. According to Richard Perloff, racial lynchings had become commonplace in part of because of the media’s failures to bring the injustice into light.

He quotes a white resident of Emelle, Alabama, who questioned a reporter’s inquiry into the killing of an African American: “A few white residents who had been on hand when the men were killed refused to talk about the events to reporters from The Tuscaloosa News. ‘What the hell are you newspaper men doing here?’ asked a white man who had been part of the vigilante group. ‘We’re just killing a few Negroes that we’ve waited too damn long about leaving for the buzzards. That’s not news’” (Raper, 1933, p. 67). The silence from the mainstream media about Black victims burned to death, hanged and dismembered embodied the normalization of white supremacist violence.

Gus Rugley, 21, was murdered in 2004 by San Francisco police who stopped his car for no known reason, surrounded it and fired at him from all sides – 36 bullets hitting him, six of them in the head.
Activists and Black journalists responded to American media that often downplayed the practice of white-on-Black violence and/or named African Americans as deserving of torment and murder. According to Perloff, writing in The Journal of Black Studies: “It is next to impossible to locate a newspaper article that does not identify the victim as a Negro or that refrains from suggesting that the accused was guilty of the crime and therefore deserving of punishment. For example, The New Orleans Picayune described an African-American who was lynched in Hammond, Louisiana, for robbery as a ‘big, burly Negro’ and a ‘Black wretch.’”

Lige Daniels is lynched in Center, Texas, on Aug. 3, 1920. Center is the county seat near all-Black East Liberty, where Bay View publisher Willie Ratcliff was born and raised. Like Ida B. Wells, he is committed to ending lynchings, whether by the KKK or police, and is being recognized by New American Media with a community advocacy award for being the first and sometimes only voice challenging the official version of police killings.
Amid this silence and sanctioning of white-on-Black violence, Ida B. Wells-Barnett and others within the Black press not only documented each and every lynching, but in providing the graphic details, they challenged the very fabric of American racism. From displaying signs announcing “A Lynching Happened Today” to the publication of various pamphlets, activists worked to force America to come to grips with the contradiction between its purported creed and the ongoing violence perpetuated within its boundaries.

The more things change, the more things stay the same.

The history of racist violence, of lynchings, of state violence, or a complicit media and systemic injustice, all of which define the era of Jim Crow, remain a reality despite our purportedly post-racial moment. A recent report from the Malcolm X Grassroots Movement (MXGM) entitled “Report on Extrajudicial Killings of 110 Black People” elucidates the contemporary struggle against lynchings.

A video seen by hundreds of thousands shows Kenneth Harding fighting for his life in a fast-growing pool of his own blood while police aim their guns at him and the crowd to prevent anyone from aiding or comforting him. After a half hour, medics finally arrived, but it was too late. – Video frame: TheOneNonly457
In the first six months of 2012, the police, security guards and self-appointed agents of “justice” have killed 110 African-American men, women, and children. Since the report’s publication, 10 additional killings have been confirmed, which means that from Jan. 1 through June 30, 2012, there was one killing every 36 hours.

Of those who lost their lives at the hands of a police or security officer, 47 did not have a weapon at the time of their killing. Another 40 were said to have a weapon – including a cane, a BB gun and a toy gun – although witnesses have disputed these purported facts. A small number of those killed, 21 people, were armed at the time they were sentenced to death. None were afforded the presumed right of innocence until proven guilty.

Denika Chatman, mother of Kenneth Harding, the 19-year-old murdered by SFPD over a $2 Muni fare on July 16, 2011, speaks to the press on July 13, 2012, about the weekend of activities to commemorate the first anniversary of his death. She held the press conference on the sidewalk at Third Street and Oakdale in Hunters Point where Kenny bled to death. – Photo: Poor News Network
Many of these deaths are the consequences of stop and frisk policies, racial profiling and a culture of white racist stereotyping of African Americans as criminals and suspects. According to Rosa Clemente, a member of Malcolm X Grassroots Movement and former vice presidential candidate of the Green Party, “Nowhere is a Black woman or man safe from racial profiling, invasive policing, constant surveillance and overriding suspicion.” In the press release, she notes, “All Black people – regardless of education, class, occupation, behavior or dress – are subject to the whims of the police in this epidemic of state initiated or condoned violence.”

The study showed that 43 percent of those killed on these streets, prior to any legal proceedings, were stopped because of “suspicious behavior or appearance” or because of traffic violations. Another 10 percent were not involved in criminal behavior at all, with another 18 percent resulting from 911 calls, including several from family members seeking assistance with individuals suffering from mental illness, only to see them killed in the streets.

Raymond Smoot, beaten by guards in Baltimore’s Central Booking Jail in 2005, died in the hospital.
With only 33 percent of the killings resulting from an actual investigation, we must begin to ask: Police are protecting and serving whom?

Among its victims are Rekia Boyd, an innocent bystander shot and killed in Chicago; Dante Price, who was shot 22 times while trying to pick up his children; and Travis Henderson, a “a suicidal man sitting in a church parking lot with a gun. When he got out of the car, he allegedly pointed the gun at an officer and was shot.”

An Orange County sheriff killed Manuel Loggins, a former marine and father of two daughters, in front of his children. The “sheriff initially said he feared for his own safety and later revised his story to say he feared for the girls’ safety.”

Holding a sign protesting the Chicago PD murder of their aunt, Rekia Boyd, are Omarr Hatcher, 9, and Darian Boyd, 7. The protest, one of many, was held April 7, 2012. – Photo: Jim Slosiarek, KCRG
And there is Anton Barrett, “who was allegedly driving without headlights and running stop signs when a DUI Saturation Patrol signaled him to stop. According to the report, “he led the officers on a high speed chase; when his tires went flat, he fled on foot. One officer confronted him in a darkened alley and shot him multiple times, claiming he thought he saw him pull a ‘metallic object’ from his sweatshirt pocket. After Barrett was shot, he attempted to rise and a second officer tasered him. He was cuffed and died at hospital. Police admit they mistook wallet for gun.”

The history of state violence, of the consequences of systemic racism, a story often imagined as a concluded chapter in American history, remains a grave problem of the 21st century.

Raheim Brown was murdered by Oakland school police as he sat, unarmed, in a car after a school dance. Supporters of Raheim and other Blacks murdered by police joined in the Oscar Grant Memorial March and Rally Jan. 1, 2012. – Photo: Bradley Stuart, Indybay
In the spirit of Ida B. Wells and other freedom fighters, this report continues the tradition of bearing witness to the atrocities of state violence. Under a cloud of silence, denial and denied accountability, the death toll rises.

While the media, political “leaders” and citizens alike ignore and justify these killings by blaming the victims, MXGM and this report make clear that African Americans continue to live “without sanctuary” in America, demanding that we not only “bear witness” to these ongoing atrocities but join them “in demanding that the Obama administration implement a National Plan of Action for Racial Justice to stop these killings and other human rights violations being committed by the government.”

A lynching happened today. One happens every 36 hours. Will another happen tomorrow?

As Ida B. Wells-Barnett powerfully reminds us, “The way to right wrongs is to turn the light of truth upon them.”

Ida B. Wells
To read the report, visit http://mxgm.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/MXGM-Report-on-Black-People-Executed-without-Trial-by-Police.pdf. For information on the petition, visit http://www.ushrnetwork.org/content/webform/trayvon-martin-petition.

David J. Leonard is associate professor in the Department of Critical Culture, Gender and Race Studies at Washington State University, Pullman. He is the author of the just released “After Artest: Race and the War on Hoop” (SUNY Press), a regular contributor to New Black Man, layupline, Feminist Wire and Urban Cusp and a frequent contributor to Ebony, Slam and Racialicious as well as a past contributor to Loop21, The Nation and The Starting Five. He blogs at No Tsuris. Follow him on Twitter: drdavidjleonard. This story first appeared on the Huffington Post.

 

8 thoughts on “A police lynching happens every 36 hours

  1. wallace

    America is waging an undeclared war against the black community to force it into passive silence! This is very similar to what we experienced after the 12 years of reconstruction following the Hayes-Tilden backroom agreement to pull federal troops out of the south in 1877. This is not an aberration or series of mistakes but a national,unwritten,policy. America doesn´t declare war anymore. And because it isn´t announced we don´t know what to think!

    Reply
    1. Oakland

      No. Cops are responding to crime and if you're familiar with stats, you'll note young black males are well represented w/ regard to robberies, murders, and violence.

      Reply
      1. John Mulligan

        This is what I don't understand. The people who host this website know that thousands of young black men are killed by other young black men every year. Gang violence is, in fact, the top killer among young black men. So why ignore it? Is it shame? You just don't want to admit it? Is it ok, you think it's not a big deal? I would understand if the writers contributing to this website complained about gang crime and police misconduct but why totally disregard what is clearly the bigger problem? It just makes no sense. It's as if you don't care if these young men die, you only care who kills them. To make it worse, the writers here literealy invent instances of police misconduct to support this position, as in the case of Mr. Harding. But it's so obviously a fabrication I find it hard to believe that the readers actually buy it.

        Reply
        1. The 56%

          They ignore it because like all niggers they would rather blame someone else for their problems then try and make things better.

          Reply
  2. Selina

    No Race ( the white race) can give a moral compase to anyone

    Especially when it (the White race) has orchestrated and carried Saturday night lynchings

    And is now committed acts of Terror on it's own Aurora, and Columbine Colorado, Oaklahoma City-Federal Building, the World Trade Center 93' and 2001 to include others Vietnam, Iraq, Graneda, Japan and Afghanistan

    Reply
  3. junya

    Right now, the public's (including activists') programming is to react strongly to certain types of killings by police. As with so many things in the US, "race" tops the list: the "white-cop-kills-unarmed-young-black-man" script. But I continue to argue that this is a bug, a flaw, an error in thinking that needs to be fixed, not carried on and on. We are looking at it wrong, and so are likely to come up with wrong solutions.

    Discriminatory policing and extrajudical executions are problems that intersect, but they are NOT the same. We are currently focusing more on the discriminatory aspect than the use of force. That is so absurd that I am almost embarrassed to point it out. When discriminatory policing ends, and a cop slams my face into the concrete, I will NOT be thinking "That's ok – he's not doing it just because I'm black"! The immediate problems presented by this flawed thinking is:

    1. The state has had decades of experience showing how difficult discrimination is to prove. That makes it a comfort zone for the state.

    2. The public does not normally react as strongly to police killings that do not fit this mold. Thus the state does *less* explaining for killing less-privileged "white" youths (for examples, see the 2009 report "Aftermath of the execution of Oscar Grant: Everything’s under control" at http://sfbayview.com/2009/aftermath-of-the-execut

    3. It divides the resistance by ethnicity, when we need to unite!

    “The way to right wrongs is to turn the light of truth upon them.”
    The biggest obstacle in fighting US extrajudicial executions is the lack of data. As I reported in 2008 ("The Olympic Debate: 'Tis The Season To Be Phony" at http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2008/04/16/18493… in 2007 the Justice Department released its first accounting of arrest-related deaths (ARD), that placed the number of police homicides as averaging one every day (exceeding all developed countries, a much higher rate than the police of the US allies, Australia and UK, more comparable to India). This was supposed to be an annual accounting, but was never updated – until four years later! (In the update for 2003-2009, the police homicide rate remains at an average of one per day) And, of course, as the update states: "Arrest-related deaths are under-reported". Moreover, the update included this stunning admission from the Justice Department's statistics office (BJS):

    "In an effort to increase the ARD program’s national coverage [because reporting is voluntary, not mandatory], BJS began exploring the use of internet-based searches to retrospectively identify arrest-related deaths occurring from 2007 through 2009. BJS staff conducted online media searches based on 12 key terms and identified websites dedicated to either in-custody deaths or deaths associated with the usage of specific weapons, such as conductive energy devices. "
    (http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/pub/ascii/ard0309st.txt)

    In plain English: "Since the local cops don't bother to tell us how many they are killing, we have to listen out for the scream of grieving families and outraged public on websites before we can tick off another kill…". This monstrous, mindless, murder machine would be a joke – if it wasn't such a horror. Yet this confirms that the state is well aware of the risk of ignoring public concern over extrajudical executions. Our job is to keep the heat on.

    Reply
  4. show band visa sila

    I have been browsing online more than 3 hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It’s pretty worth sufficient for me. Personally, if all web owners and bloggers made just right content as you probably did, the internet will probably be much more useful than ever before.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

BayView Classifieds - ads, opportunities, announcements
San Francisco Comcast