Support SF BayView
Donate or Subscribe to SF Bay View
Follow Us Twitter Facebook

Justice for Andy Lopez, 13: A child is dead at the hands of Sonoma County sheriff’s deputies

October 25, 2013

by Elbert “Big Man” Howard

Students march Andy Lopez’ murder site Santa Rosa 102313 by AP
Demanding justice for Andy Lopez, students from Elsie Allen High School and Lawrence Cook Middle School march on Oct. 23 toward the site where 13-year-old Andy Lopez was murdered the previous day by a Sonoma County sheriff’s deputy near the corner of Moorland and West Robles in Santa Rosa. – Photo: Jay Connor, Santa Rosa Press Democrat
As a founding member of the Black Panther Party and also of PACH, the Police Accountability Clinic and Helpline of Sonoma County, I am all too familiar with police abuse. PACH, an all-volunteer organization, was formed to take reports of police misconduct after community meetings which occurred because of a series of killings in 2007.

I am making this statement on behalf of myself and PACH and in response and protest to the killing of Andy Lopez, 13 years of age, by law enforcement.

One of the reasons that the Black Panther Party was formed in 1966, and why they fought so hard many years ago, was to have community control of the police – to make the police accountable to the community. In the present atmosphere that still exists of racial profiling and police abuse, the politicians and law enforcement agencies are accountable to no one.

Now, 47 years later, here I am, waking up to the news that on Oct. 22, the very day we recognize as the National Day of Protest Against Police Brutality, this 13-year-old child has been shot down and killed by Sonoma County sheriff’s deputies.

On Oct. 22, the very day we recognize as the National Day of Protest Against Police Brutality, this 13-year-old child has been shot down and killed by Sonoma County sheriff’s deputies.

Clearly, police misconduct remains an on-going issue in our community as the civil and human rights of people in our communities are ignored and violated. We all need to protest the police abuse, racial profiling and the killings by law enforcement that continue to occur in our community.

Law enforcement, in this county, is a system against the people. The treatment of people at the hands of law enforcement remains an ongoing issue and, instead of improving, it has clearly worsened. The fact that this child has been gunned down is just one example of an entire unjust system.

Parents Rodrigo Lopez, Sujey Annel Cruz Cazere of Andy Lopez, 13, murdered by Sonoma Cty sheriff’s deputies Santa Rosa 102313 by AP
Rodrigo Lopez comforts his wife, Sujey Annel Cruz Cazere, on Oct. 23, the day after their son, Andy Lopez, 13, was murdered by a Sonoma County sheriff’s deputy who reportedly saw him carrying a toy gun. – Photo: AP
Details of these deaths in the past and present are always “not for public record.” The so-called details take weeks to be obtained. We, as community members, demand an accounting of this shooting. We want to know why this child is dead.

In order to protest the police abuse and racial profiling that continues to thrive in our community, we need to take action in various ways.

One of these ways is that we need to cease supporting, as taxpayers, the funding of laws, law enforcement agencies and criminal penalties that do not work and violate our civil, constitutional and human rights.

Some of you may remember, back in May of 2000, the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, after investigating charges of police misconduct in Sonoma County, recommended that there should be an office formed, independent of the District Attorney’s, to both investigate and prosecute cases of police abuse. It never happened. Why? Was it due to a lack of community political will?

Are we to continue to ignore the injustices in our community? Are we to continue to support laws that erode our basic human and civil rights? We must form alliances within our community in order to deal with this issue of misconduct by law enforcement. We must do it now before someone else’s child lies dead at the age of 13.

Black Media Appreciation Night Big Man 112612 by Bill Jennings, It's About Time
Elbert “Big Man” Howard displays the award he received on behalf of the Black Panther Party at Black Media Appreciation Night on Nov. 26, 2012. – Photo: Bill Jennings, It’s About Time
Elbert “Big Man” Howard is one of the original six founding members of the Black Panther Party; he served as the first editor of the Black Panther newspaper and as party spokesperson. He is also, more recently, a founding member of the Police Accountability Clinic and Helpline (PACH). An activist, author and lecturer, he resides in Sonoma County and can be reached at

Solidarity statements

Below are three statements of solidarity with the family of Andy Lopez and the movement for justice.

Statement by Adrienne DeSantis, mother of Richard DeSantis, who was killed by Santa Rosa police in 2007:

“My heart goes out to the family and friends of Andy Lopez. The finality of Andy’s passing from this life, like that of my own son, brings another terrible wave of urgency that we keep our fingers on the pulse of what is happening around us and that we express our love often, before it is too late.

“Regarding the many, many unnecessary deaths by law enforcement, given that the policies in place bring cruel results, why do we let them continue? There’s something backward and very inhumane about shooting first, then handcuffing the dying or already dead person, and then going through the motions of administering first aid.

“All lives have worth, so we must insist on policies that attempt to save all lives. To accomplish that, law enforcement officers must act under the assumption that people are not robots but are thinking, feeling individuals.

Andy Lopez with trumpets“When weapons are aimed at people by police and orders are shouted, we can expect that fear, confusion and a desire for self-preservation will be one natural reaction. A delayed response is another possibility, while the person is processing what is happening. It is not reasonable to insist under those conditions that commands must be obeyed or the person annihilated.

“How about talking to the person in question in a non-threatening manner? How about asking relevant questions? In many instances, reaching out as an ally is bound to have better results. Vibes are contagious. Tension creates desperation. We need real authorities who are calm in crises and who see the preciousness of all lives.

“The old refrains of, ‘I thought he had a gun’ or ‘It was a quickly evolving situation’ just don’t wash any more. We pay officers to think on their feet and to be courageous. Responders must take an honest look at their part in how things evolve and comprehend that by taking a threatening posture toward citizens, the officers themselves are escalating the situation.

“I know the difference between a competent response by police and a disastrous one. I have had both. And when it was unexpectedly helpful, I took the time to say so to the responder’s supervisor.

“If police want to be respected and trusted in the community, they must not only be courageous and respect the people they are paid to serve but also be truthful when things go wrong and refuse to align themselves with indefensible patterns of conduct that give the whole profession a bad name. Let’s work together for positive change.”

RIP Andy LopezStatement by Marty McReynolds, chair of the Sonoma County Chapter of the ACLU, on behalf of the chapter’s board of directors:

“The fatal shooting of 13-year-old Andy Lopez by a Sonoma County sheriff’s deputy in Southwest Santa Rosa on Tuesday is a tragedy that underlines the need for an independent civilian review board with subpoena powers to investigate police conduct and report to the public. This was strongly recommended by the U.S. Civil Rights Commission in 2000 following its investigation of fatal incidents involving police in Sonoma County. Only such an independent investigation can supply the facts needed for corrective recommendations and give the public confidence in the actions of the agents pledged to protect our community.”

Statement by Megan Gordon, member of Stop Mass Incarceration, who was protesting police abuse with the October 22nd Coalition at Santa Rosa City Hall before Andy Lopez was murdered by law enforcement on the National Day of Protest to Stop Police Brutality, Repression and the Criminalization of a Generation:

“We are heartbroken at the shooting death of Andy Lopez. This needs to be the last act of needless police violence in our county. The fact that it occurred on Oct. 22, the National Day of Protest Against Police Brutality, highlights the truth that our youth are viewed as criminals by law enforcement.”

Santa Rosa cops encourage kids to handle guns

Only two years ago, in August 2011 at the South Park Day and Night Festival in Martin Luther King Jr. Park, Santa Rosa law enforcement – the police SWAT team in this case, backed by the Mayor’s Gang Prevention Task Force – encouraged children to handle guns. A public outcry followed, and Elbert “Big Man” Howard wrote this letter to the editor of the Santa Rosa Press Democrat, who did not publish it:

Santa Rosa SWAT gun booth for children MLK Park festival 0811 by Attila Nagy
Young children were encouraged by law enforcement at an August 2011 festival in Santa Rosa’s Martin Luther King Jr. Park to handle guns that are designed for no other purpose than to terrorize and kill people. Yet when sheriff’s deputies saw 13-year-old Andy Lopez carrying a toy gun, they murdered him. – Photo: Attila Nagy
“It is interesting to read letters praising law officers whose latest actions ‘to reach the community’ included a demonstration of force and weaponry for the children whose rights they violate daily.

“Law officers and ICE agents routinely descend on these community members, racially profiling them, harassing and detaining them. They impound their vehicles, bust into their homes and arrest them, for little or no reason. Innocent community members are shot and killed with this same type of weaponry.

“Yet here they are, proudly displaying and allowing children to handle their weapons. Do you think the parents of these children were asked for permission first?

“We cannot comprehend what the intent of all this was, but we do know that justice does not come from the barrel of a gun, and we believe many of these same children already know this fact. Demonstrating how much killing power is available to impressionable children is not protecting or serving the community, but is just a further reminder of the power and terror available for some to exert control over others and how easy it is for those armed in such a manner to take lives if and when they so choose.”

Justice Now! for AndyLopez flier


12 thoughts on “Justice for Andy Lopez, 13: A child is dead at the hands of Sonoma County sheriff’s deputies

  1. Shepherd Bliss

    My appreciations to "Big Man" for this article and to those whom he quotes. Every day since this killing there have been actions in Santa Rosa against this unnecessary killing and there will be more, including today. A joint statement by various groups is being prepared and a mass demonstration for Oct. 30, Wed., starting at 5 p.m. in the Latino Roseland neighborhood. This matter is not over yet.

  2. jesse blankenship

    In my opinion maybe instead of blaming the cops for mistaking a convincable looking toy ak47 for the real deal where did this kid get the toy?? did mom an dad get it for him?? maybe realistic looking toy guns should be baned.I belive socioty is failing our youth regardless of nationality. there constantly fed garbage wich includes video games that award points for killing etc. giving them toy guns to fake kill eachother so the problem is not with the police whom im sure are privy to the recent student killings and are not going to go rite up to anyone holding an assault rifle to determin if its real.stop letting video games rgang rap and hollywood trash raise our youth.cmon moms an dads step up an take controll.

    1. Porter Law

      Anyone who knows anything about guns should have known this was not a real AK-47. I have seen pictures of the actual model of air gun thia innocent victim of police brutality and profiling was carrying and it looks nothimg like a real gun. The sonoma sheriff’s department has a long histoey of police brutality against ots own citizens and used this as an opportunity to intimidate and profile and murder. They can try to displace tje blame on the victim, bit there is no excuse they can give that justifies thier actions. Even if the boy had a real ak 47 they still murdered him. He has the right to bear arms. This is america last I checked, it was our right as citizens. They shoy him in the back like cowards. If it were anyone other than suposed peqce officers they would be in jail and ultimately in jail for life, or in thr electric chair. These disgraces should not recieve special treatment, infact they should be held to a higher standard. And lets not forget, these thugs inserted themselves into this situation. This boy was not acting agressive he was walking home, he was not acting suspicious and he was not breaking the law in any way. Yet he ended up dead, shot in the back at lrast 7 times. These thugs need to be in jail or, better yet, death by firing squad. This needs toxbe a wake up call to all Americans. We have willing relinquished our rights our of fear. We are now less free and less safe than we were. We need to take control of the organizations that are suposed to serve us. If we don’t we will become the servants in a tyranical police state.

      1. jabrown77

        Thanks for your great post. Wish more in the communities of this broken society shared the same. I certainly 100% agree with you. Andy Lopez's life loss was unjustified and the leo should be put on trial and be held accountable to full extent of law and indicted.

  3. Peter Phillips

    Now that the FBI has joined the investigation it is clear that a full cover up will occur. Certainly the fact that one sheriff didn't fire his weapon and the other one emptied his gun is a problem for the sheriff's office to explain the difference in behavior. Bringing in the FBI is supposed to offset this problem, but in reality only shows the full extent of centralized power inside our racist police state.

    1. seamus

      I think you have the wrong idea about investigations and how they work. You don't necessarily want an organization to investigate itself. It leads to potential conflict of interest problems. This is why the California Highway Patrol investigates city and county police/sheriff traffic accidents.

  4. StanR

    The death of Andy Lopez is tragic but his bad discussion should be held accountable. He was walking in the street carrying an airsoft replica of an AK-47 (something airsoft merchants strongly discourage) without the orange barrel plug (as required by law). Because he was walking in the streets with one of the most deadliest assault rifles, the Sheriff Deputies had to assume the worst case scenario. Guess what, cops don't have mind reading abilities so they had to make a critical choice based on what they saw and what they know. More can be read here:

  5. Orangeplow

    I love the “Justice for Andy” posters have a picture of him when he was 8 or 9 to draw sympathy .Sorry, a 13 yo can look thuggy and imposing, not to mention an age when kids are entrenchng themselves in gangs and required to do unspeakable things for initiation. The SR cops are not dumb. They see lots of things and are intimate with gang and youth culture. This is a failure of family, accountability and common sense. If the cops tell you to drop something…. DROP It! … Darwin:1, Kid: 0

    1. Hiphipnotherapist

      Orangeplow your comments are so biased and yes, based on what you think happened and not on facts.
      To blame his parents for the crime that happened is of such base thinking you should be ashamed of yourself. However, their are some people in our society that are as sick as the officer who killed Andy Lopez. You sir, did not know Andy Lopez. How can you imply he was a thug, a gang member. On the day he was killed he was on private property, just a kid having fun with a toy gun.

  6. jabrown77

    Great article from Elbert Howard, on this unnecesarry tragedy. Its a heartwarming article that, unlike most other news articles that cover high profile tragedies that are glossed over with the basic info from other writers. However, in "Big Man's" article his superb prose presented with eloquence comes at a perfect time in light of crisis that continues to plague our society, especially a society thats been putting our young African American and Latino population live's at the risk of out of control law enforcement. Justice for Andy Lopez. Rest In Peace Andy!!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

BayView Classifieds - ads, opportunities, announcements
San Francisco Comcast