Moments before he was killed, Oscar Grant was punched in the face – but not by the BART officer who shot him. A cellphone video released by KTVU Jan. 23 shows another BART officer, identified as Tony Pirone, punching Grant just before he was shot by BART Officer Johannes Mehserle, who was arrested on murder charges Jan. 13.

Pirone, who punched Grant in the face, is the same officer who investigators say had his knee on Grant’s neck when the 22-year-old man was shot and killed on the Fruitvale BART station platform in Oakland at about 2 a.m. on New Year’s Day. Aside from Mehserle, no BART officers have been charged with wrongdoing.

Although unmentioned in the KTVU report, the video could potentially incriminate another BART officer. Since the female officer is shown in the video observing her colleague punching Grant, she would have been required to report what she saw to authorities.


  1. Video clearly shows Pirone hitting him in the face.

    No wonder people hate cops so much, cops are allowed to get away with crap like this all the time.

  2. It’s a fact, that on audio tape, Pirone is heard to be yelling; ‘Bitch ass n—–.’

    Please please please tell me Pirone’s going to be doing some jail time for this. No cop should get away with such obvious unacceptable behavior – he’s on the clock, he’s in uniform – that comes with definite, clear cut responsibilities.

  3. I intended to compose you that very little note just to say thanks a lot over again with the beautiful ideas you have shared in this article. It was quite tremendously generous of people like you to convey easily just what many people could have distributed for an ebook to make some profit on their own, specifically considering that you might have done it in case you considered necessary. The guidelines likewise worked to become a good way to understand that someone else have a similar keenness just like my very own to know somewhat more when it comes to this issue. I know there are a lot more fun occasions ahead for those who scan through your website.

Leave a Reply