Family of Oscar Grant celebrates victory, Mehserle to face murder charge


by dave id

When Judge Donald Clay said he had no doubt that then BART cop Johannes Mehserle intended to fire his gun at Oscar Grant, his ruling brought Oscar’s family to tears. Wanda Johnson, Oscar’s mother, said, “Even if Mehserle goes to jail, his family … will have a loss just like I will have a loss … My loss – I will have to go to the gravesite and look at my son’s headstone.” – Video: APA victory in the campaign for justice for Oscar Grant III was celebrated today after the presiding judge, Superior Court Judge C. Don Clay, concluded the preliminary hearing in the trial of Johannes Mehserle by ruling that the former BART police officer will stand trial for murder. June 18 is the date Mehserle is scheduled to appear back in court and declare his plea of guilt or innocence before the full trial begins.

The defense had called numerous witnesses over the course of the three-week hearing, including Mehserle’s fellow officers who were with him on the Fruitvale BART platform on Jan. 1 when Oscar Grant was murdered. The testimony of the BART officers did not help Mehserle’s case, as they were continually contradicted by the evidence from multiple videos shot by BART passengers that night. Prosecutor David Stein was very thorough in his questioning and cross examination, exposing the numerous lies of the BART police officers.

In the courtroom at the conclusion of the hearing today, family and friends waited anxiously to hear what the judge might say. When Judge Clay announced his decision, they broke out in tears of joy, amazed that rare justice for a police murder might actually be realized. While family and friends know that this is just a first step towards achieving justice for Oscar Grant, they were relieved, elated and a little bit giddy that the efforts of defense attorney Michael Rains failed to have the initial murder charge reduced or dropped.

Here, trigger man Johannes Mehserle’s defense attorney, Michael Rains, questions BART Officer Tony Pirone as Mehserle (left) and Judge Donald Clay look on. On cross examination, Pirone admitted that the position Oscar Grant was in just seconds before he was shot made it impossible for him to have grabbed and used a weapon even if he had had one, the Oakland Tribune reported. “I didn't see the hands, so I didn't see a threat,” Pirone said. “It didn't pose a threat to me ... or any other officer.” – Drawing: Joan LynchAfter the hearing today, family and friends gathered in downtown Oakland to share a celebratory dinner. During the meal, a corporate TV news report came on which gave the story just about one minute. Tom Mehserle, father of Johannes, was quoted in the broadcast as saying that the preliminary hearing was a sham and that no justice could be reached in Oakland, an obvious attempt to push for the trial venue to be moved out of Alameda County. Undeterred in their mission for justice for Oscar Grant, family and friends then went to Lafayette Square Park to discuss their feelings about the result of the hearing.

Gathered in the park were Sister Beatrice of the Nation of Islam; Yolanda Turner, mother of Nigel and Jacky Bryson; Tracy Cooper, mother of Michael Greer; Rosemary Mesa, mother of Sophina Mesa and grandmother of Oscar Grant’s daughter, Tatiana; Zaporia Smith, mother of J2 Codwell; Diana Marks, godmother of Oscar Grant; Jack Bryson, father of Nigel and Jacky Bryson; and Jacky Bryson, who, along with the other sons named here, was with Oscar Grant on the night the BART police accosted the group and murdered Oscar Grant. They expressed gratitude for Judge Clay, Prosecutor Stein and numerous supporters who are fighting along with the family for justice.

For video, audio and written reports related to the Mehserle preliminary hearing at the Alameda County Courthouse, see

Dave Id is a journalist and activist who has thoroughly documented the Justice for Oscar Grant Movement with vision, sensitivity and consummate expertise in prolific postings at


  1. what a shame. this officer made a mistake and the racist blacks are out to hang him. i sure miss the old days.

  2. I am so thankful that the BART cop will be tried for the murder of Oscar Grant. Let this send a message to all cops that like the nurder of Idryss Stelly at the SF Metreon when 9 cops fired over 4 dozen bullets into a young black man who was an honor student. He was unarmed and they knew it. He was having a psychological break down and the uneducated cops killed him for it. Then SF Mayor Brown had ordered all SF cops to have 40 hrs. of psychoglogical training but these 9 cops did not have theirs yet. Idryss may still be alive today if they had.
    May justice be served and the BART cop get his death sentence.
    Rev. Sandra Decker

  3. And it’s people like prop187 who make me sick to my stomach. It’s racist people like that greatens the atrophy of this society.

  4. In the “old days” sick perverse murderous men were allowed to destroy human life at will, a gift (life) they did not give but also could not understand for they have no souls. The “old days” will come only when they do it will only be you and your kind prop187 that will be there for it, enduring the same egregious acts committed against others. As disgusting as you are prop187 and those like you, I hope that people are praying for you because you need it.

Leave a Reply