Minister Christopher Muhammad speaks during a press conference on Tuesday, May 1, 2018, at the Nation of Islam school playground overlooking the Hunters Point Shipyard to announce the filing of a $27.3 billion lawsuit on behalf of Bayview residents alleging they were misled about the toxic cleanup of the shipyard Superfund site. – Photo: Kevin N. Hume, SF Examiner

Learn more and JOIN THE LAWSUIT at the townhall meeting on Saturday, June 9, 1-3 p.m., at the Joseph Lee Rec Center, 1395 Mendell St. in Bayview Hunters Point

by Ahimsa Porter Sumchai MD

“Scientists, environmentalists and the people of Hunters Point have been pushed back and discredited by government officials and developers – until now.” – Attorneys for plaintiffs Charles A. Bonner and A. Cabral Bonner

Charles A. Bonner, Esq.

In 1991, delegates to the First National People of Color Environmental Leadership Summit in Washington, D.C., defined environmental justice in the preamble to their “Principles of Environmental Justice,” which states in part: “Environmental justice calls for universal protection from nuclear testing, extraction, production and disposal of toxic and hazardous wastes and poisons and nuclear testing that threaten the fundamental right to clean air, land, water and food. … Environmental justice demands the cessation of the production of all toxins, hazardous wastes and radioactive materials, and that all past and current producers be held accountable to the people for detoxification of the contaminants at the point of production. … Environmental justice protects the right of victims of environmental injustice to receive full compensation and reparations for damages as well as quality health care.”

In adopting the San Francisco Precautionary Principle Ordinance in 2003, the Board of Supervisors declared: “Every San Franciscan has an equal right to a healthy and safe environment. This requires that our air, water, earth, and food be of sufficiently high standard that individuals and communities can live healthy, fulfilling and dignified lives. The duty to enhance, protect and preserve San Francisco’s environment rests on the shoulders of government, residents, citizen groups and businesses alike.”

The Precautionary Principle requires careful analysis based on the best available science when threats of serious or irreversible damage to people exist and lack of full scientific certainty about cause and effect shall not be viewed as sufficient reason for the city to postpone effective measure to prevent degradation of the environment and protect the health of its citizens.

The first high profile test of the power of the Precautionary Principle in Bayview Hunters Point came on Sept. 25, 2007, when the San Francisco Board of Education unanimously adopted Resolution 79-25A1 In Opposition to Lennar Corporation’s Hunters Point Naval Shipyard Development and in Support of the Community’s Demand for a Temporary Stoppage and Independent Health and Safety Assessment to Protect Our Students and Their Families.

That courageous stance taken by elected government officials came as the direct result of the actions of a young worker who, in October 2006, blew the whistle on Lennar’s shipyard development, galvanizing a coalition of students, teachers, educators, workers, activists and families who stood unified in opposition to the toxic dust generated by grading and demolition activities at a federal Superfund site.

A. Cabral Bonner, Esq.

The National Priorities List is the list of sites of national priority among the known releases or threatened releases of hazardous substances, pollutants or contaminants eligible for long-term remedial action financed under the federal Superfund program established in 1980 as the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act or CERCLA.

That young worker was named Christopher Carpenter and, as we reported, he gave his life in duty to community. Carpenter died slowly of a rare cancer not previously reported in an African American and at his death in 2016 believed it was the result of numerous unprotected exposures to toxic dust while working on Parcel A of the Hunters Point Shipyard.

But the shipyard development rolled forward like a bulldozer blade and never stopped. The Board of Supervisors abandoned the Precautionary Principle and bowed to the corporate greed and tractor power of the master developer, its puppets and corrupt overlords seated in City Hall and within the upper echelons of the federal government. Today there are 300 homes with families on former shipyard Parcel A.

The shipyard development plowed forward dragging with it a declining population of African Americans who by 2018 represented 3 percent of the city’s population and nearly 40 percent of its homeless. In 2009 the San Francisco Department of Public Health stopped tracking health surveillance data on its public website for the 94124 zip code in the face of mounting evidence the chronic exposure to particle pollution due to development of a federal Superfund site was contributing to an enormous excess burden of cardiopulmonary disease evident in excess years of life lost due to lung, trachea and bronchial cancers, congestive heart failure, heart attacks and an inexplicably high rate of emergency department visits due to adult asthma.

The shipyard development plowed forward – and on May Day, May 1, 2018, the Day of Reckoning arrived.

A media advisory, headed, “Victims of Hunters Point Shipyard File $27 Billion Class Action Lawsuit,” announced: “On behalf of named plaintiffs and thousands of other victims to be named including residents, deceased family members and unborn children, renowned civil rights attorney Charles Bonner has filed a $27 billion lawsuit for damages arising from generational threats of cancer and other incurable illnesses relating to the documented fraud perpetrated by U.S. Navy contractor Tetra Tech in assuring Hunters Point residents and the City of San Francisco that the radiated land at the Hunters Point Shipyard had been cleaned. …

“Black, brown and other people of color who have resided in Hunters Point since World War II have long complained of the unusually high incidences of cancer, chronic diseases and death they have suffered and witnessed, believing this excess burden of disease was rooted in the toxins and radiation generated by the nuclear bomb and war ships made, serviced, launched and deconstructed at the Hunters Point Naval Shipyard. Over the last decade, community groups led by Nation of Islam Minister Christopher Muhammad have demanded the truth about the health risks to the community arising from the toxicity in and adjacent to the Superfund site. Concerned citizens including Dr. Ahimsa Sumchai have spent decades investigating the impacts of radiation exposure at the shipyard and documenting patterns of illness peculiar to this community.

Chris Carpenter and his family

“Scientists, environmentalists and the people of Bayview Hunters Point have been pushed back and discredited by government officials beholden to the master developer – until now. Tetra Tech whistleblowers have opened the floodgates of truth, and the plaintiffs in this lawsuit will prove that they have suffered irreparable, generational harm because the Hunters Point Naval Shipyard has remained toxic with radiation and a host of toxic substances since World War II.”

The attorneys who filed the suit are Charles A. Bonner and his son, A. Cabral Bonner of Bonner & Bonner, a firm with an impressive list of outcomes on many challenging lawsuits. Principle plaintiffs in the class action suit filed in Superior Court of California County of San Francisco on May 1, 2018, are Bayview Hunters Point residents and Danielle Carpenter, widow of deceased community hero and Parcel A worker and whistleblower Christopher Carpenter. May he rest in peace!

How you can join the lawsuit

Attorneys Charles and Cabral Bonner are holding meetings where residents can learn more about the class action lawsuit and get help filling out an information packet to join it. They ask that everyone spread the word that all people living, working or studying in the community of Bayview Hunters Point from 2004 to the present are eligible to join the suit.

The first meeting was held May 25, and more will take place on June 9 and 22. Watch the Facebook page, Hunters Point Community Lawsuit for details. More information is also available by emailing HuntersPointLawsuit@gmail.com. The next townhall is Saturday, June 9, 1-3 p.m., at the Joseph Lee Rec Center, 1395 Mendell St. in Bayview Hunters Point.

SF Bay View Health and Environmental Science Editor Ahimsa Porter Sumchai, M.D., founding chair of the Hunters Point Naval Shipyard Restoration Advisory Board’s Radiological Subcommittee and contributor to the 2005 Draft Historical Radiological Assessment, can be reached at asumchai@gmail.com.

14 COMMENTS

  1. Cynthia Mackey born and raised in Bayview Hunters Point. My parents Felton and Lillian Mackey they had 9 children I'm there only daughter we lived in Hunters through out the 70s 80s some of the 2000s. During the 70s we lived in the unit that public housing provided my most memory was 4 West Point Rd. our unit was in front of the PG&E power plant that has since been demolished. I can remember nothing feeling very normal other than we had both parents there some household didn't have two parent household. I also remember that unit very well because that is were my mother last child died unexpectedly. Not knowing the cause looking back it makes me wonder if the environment there had anything to do with it. Looking back my family had behavior problems my Dad fought my Mom a lot and some of us didn't do very well in school all but one or two. My brothers would get in a lot off trouble in school and with the law. Everything at home was chaos. It makes me wonder if something was wrong with the atmosphere or something more the behavior with the brain. I feel like when your born you don't ask to live in a toxic environment your going to pay being poor, your going to live where no one else wants to live, survival is a everyday accuracy from the things seen and unseen. As a poor black family the chances or slim to none to making it out alive at lease half way alive. I look back on what my life was like back then and what it is now I look at my parents wedding pictures the fact they tried to raise us the best that they could. What I'm learning is that environmental exposure may have a lot to do with your mental capacity to be able to think clearly and can affect your choices. All but one off my brothers have a record the jail is what their lives surrounded by. How does these toxics affect the brain. Forgetfulness not being able to think clearly. As a adult I still called hunters Point home my Dad had separated from my Mom and lived on Cashmere where they stayed married and continued their marriage until 2015 until his death. I lived at 14 Hillview with my five children as a single parent. In that home my children were becoming ill my younger daughter and my two young boys. Dr. Nadine Burke I'll never forget her and her staff helped me with the issues my children were having. The community does have very fine doctors and she is one off them. I didn't want my sons two go down the same path as there uncles. My sons was displaying behavior problems in elementary school my child I picked up from school on day after so many episodes he looked up at me and said "mom I need a new brain" that brought tears to my eyes. making a long story short He's 16 I have since moved out of San Francisco I'm a Longshoreman moved to Vacaville Ca. My Dad died in 2015 I bought a house and my mom lives with me and my husband. my 16yearold is doing better on the other hand his brother has behavior problems he's 18. My roots are there in San Francisco the GOOD The Bad and the Ugly.
    Thank you for reading my story. For years my brothers would have a conversation about forgetting things this was when we were a lot younger so I wonder if that has anything to do with where we lived. Cynthia Salguero 415 (724-9386)

  2. Bathrooms are one other a part of the home that can be incredibly pricey and time consuming.
    Try by using a different hue of paint that accents the main colour of
    the bedroom, or use contrasting wallpaper. This is certain to get eliminate the muck and dust, making your floors look gleaming and new.

  3. Тhe turnkey franchise provider offers everything else, includіng.
    Tеll these potential customers well in adνance where the
    follⲟwing art show, craft mаrket or gallery showing will be.

    At the moment, probably the most popular forms of general marketing utiljzed by world wide web adveгtising companies is calⅼed article marketing.

  4. Tһat puts e-commerce sіtes on quite a lеvel playing field.
    Telll these potential customers well ahead of timе where the fοllowіng art show,
    ϲraft maгkеt or gaⅼlеry showing willl Ƅe.
    That’s the simplest way to confuse your websіte
    visitors making that it is hard foг them to discovger informatіon.

  5. That putgs e-commerce sitеs on a signifocant level plaуinjg field.
    Unless you happen to be finding cash for advertising yourself, the ߋnly way to generate
    foot traffic is by usіng ɑttractіve cօntent. For example іnn
    case you chаnce a ԝeightloss nutrition practice take into consіdеration partnering up using a exerciѕe website.

  6. For those that spend a lot of hours in the kitchen, rubber flooring may
    give you a more body-friendly option. One of the largest reasons
    a large number of homeowners opt out to renovate their existing property is to update the overall look-and to incorporate value to their home.
    And I actually thought up a solution to replace a well
    used broken plastic hose holder.

  7. Bᥙying іnternet media, for instance impressions, emails distributed, sp᧐nsorships,
    so on. Thee iss а larrge amount of specifіcs of freelancing or telecommuting, but outside bоoks and
    bⅼogs, it can be hɑrd to get specific advice for a hime based bսsiness.
    Keeping ɑ record of how customers vieѡ your organization, and reacting into
    it over time, is oftentimes nott enougһ.

  8. Hello! I know this is kind of off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are
    you using for this website? I’m getting fed up of WordPress because I’ve had issues with hackers and I’m looking at alternatives for another platform.
    I would be awesome if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

  9. Bathrooms are certainly one other a part of the home that
    may be incredibly pricey and time consuming. There is nothing like having everythings
    set and then the need to have all the feaures place on hold because its raining.
    And I actually thought up a strategy to replace a classic broken plastic hose holder.

  10. Greetings from Colorado! I’m bored to tears at work so I decided to browse your site on my iphone during lunch break.

    I enjoy the information you present here and can’t wait to
    take a look when I get home. I’m shocked at how fast your
    blog loaded on my cell phone .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G ..
    Anyhow, superb blog!

  11. Αnyone who says that Facebook, Twitter, My – Sρace,
    andd so on really are a ‘trend’ which will soon paass just
    isn’t steering you in the right direction. Therе are quit
    obvious systems it is ρossible to executed to assist you concentrate on yoսr organization. In order to see good results frοm tthe shortest time
    possible, there reaⅼⅼy are a few guidelines that
    yoou should followеd.

  12. The internet is a bit more just like a little nation, with various
    sects and towns liking different things. Sky-scrappers are also comparable to banners,
    but the difference is that they run vertically for the web
    page. In order to find out good success within the
    shortest time possible, there are a few guidelines that you should followed.

Leave a Reply