Saying no to power: Who was Bill Mandel and why should we care?
by Larry Pinkney
“Where justice is denied, where poverty is enforced, where ignorance prevails, and where any one class is made to feel that society is an organized conspiracy to oppress, rob and degrade them, neither persons nor property will be safe.” – Frederick Douglass
The above words of Frederick Douglass embody the very essence and life’s passion of the late William Marx “Bill” Mandel.
In the very early morning of Nov. 24, 2016, Bill passed on peacefully at his home in Kensington, California. He was 99. In his 99 years of life, Bill, as a writer, KPFA broadcast journalist, scholar, political activist and researcher touched the lives of many thousands of people nationally and globally.
Bill was an avid reader and a fiery orator – always challenging himself and those around him to think deeply and analytically, even when it was painful. He was of proud and exceedingly worthy Jewish heritage, but his calling and burning passion were those of a freedom fighter on behalf of ALL of humanity. In this calling he never flinched or wavered.
Some will remember Bill as the man who boldly and unflinchingly stood up to the congressional House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC) during the dim days of the Joseph McCarthy inquisition – when so many were cowered into submission. Others will remember Bill as the foremost scholarly Sovietologist and decades-long KPFA (Berkeley) broadcast journalist.
In his 99 years of life, Bill, as a writer, KPFA broadcast journalist, scholar, political activist and researcher touched the lives of many thousands of people nationally and globally.
Still others will remember Bill as an active defender of the human and political rights of people of color and the entire human family. I, however, will remember and cherish Bill Mandel as the man whose stalwart actions, virtually single-handedly, saved my life when I was a political prisoner in the U.S. prison gulag system. Bill wrote about that in his book, “Saying No to Power: Autobiography of a 20th Century Activist and Thinker” (1999); excerpts are reprinted below.
So why is Bill Mandel significant to Black America? The answer is that he repeatedly demonstrated not merely through word, but through his deeds that he would put his very life on the line in order to insist that full human rights be accorded to African-Americans. In this regard, Bill was a person of action who, throughout the course of his life, believed that words alone are not enough! He was for-real.
For example, Bill was among a select group of men who acted as security, in order to physically protect Paul Robeson and Robert “Bob” Thompson in 1949 at the infamous anti-Black and anti-Jewish Peekskill Riots in Peekskill, New York. Due to the physical protection by persons including Bill Mandel, both Paul Robeson and Pete Seeger sang at the concerts in Peekskill, despite the many vicious physical assaults that were carried out against those attempting to attend those concerts. One of them who was viciously assaulted was Eugene Bullard, the first African-American combat pilot in World War I, who was clubbed to the ground by state troopers and police.
Twenty years later, shortly after the brutal assassinations by police of Black Panthers Fred Hampton and Mark Clark in early December 1969 in Chicago, Bill and his courageous wife Tanya were among a small group of White people who physically stood guard in front of the office of the national headquarters of the original Black Panther Party in an effort to stop Oakland and Berkeley police from attacking that office.
So why is Bill Mandel significant to Black America? The answer is that he repeatedly demonstrated not merely through word, but through his deeds that he would put his very life on the line in order to insist that full human rights be accorded to African-Americans.
Bill maintained his principles and demonstrably showed his profound love for everyday ordinary people. Injustice incensed him and spurred him into action.
We don’t have to look only beyond the shores of this nation to find genuine heroes and s/heroes, for they have been, and remain, all around us. Bill Mandel was a modern-day John Brown. He was a true giant among humanity for ALL of us. And even on those rare occasions when we disagreed with each other, his sharp wit, his love for everyday people, his unassailable example and his unquenchable spirit kept our bond strong.
Injustice incensed him and spurred him into action.
When, back on Nov. 24, I learned of Bill’s passing, I simply could not believe it. The words of the gospel song, “How Shall I See You Through My Tears,” rushed through my mind, as I remembered that specific song from many years ago, when Bill and I went to see the live gospel performance of “The Gospel at Colonus.”
My friend and mentor for over 30 years – a warrior of and for the everyday people – had passed on! Yet the life work of Bill Mandel was not and is not in vain. Why? Because in our own individual ways, WE ARE ALL BILL MANDEL!
The best way to remember and honor Bill Mandel is to emulate him! By doing this, we honor and respect the best in ourselves. Moreover, let us remember that Bill was enhanced and supported by his wife and indispensable partner, Tanya, who preceded him in death.
Bill, your spirit and works will NEVER die! Let us remember the words of the martyred Joe Hill, who said, “Don’t mourn. Organize!”
ALL POWER TO THE PEOPLE – Black, White, Brown, Red and Yellow!
Larry Pinkney is a veteran of the Black Panther Party, the former Minister of Interior of the Republic of New Africa, a former political prisoner and the only American to have successfully self-authored his civil-political rights case to the United Nations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. In connection with his political organizing activities, Pinkney was interviewed in 1988 on the nationally televised PBS News Hour, formerly known as The MacNeil-Lehrer News Hour, and more recently on the nationally syndicated Alex Jones Show and global news channel RT (Russia Today). Pinkney is a former university instructor of political science and international relations, and his writings have been published in various places, including The Boston Globe, San Francisco BayView newspaper, Black Commentator, Intrepid Report, Global Research (Canada), Linke Zeitung (Germany), 107 Cowgate (Ireland and Scotland), and Mayihlome News (Azania/South Africa). Larry Pinkney wrote the foreword to internationally known peace activist and human rights advocate Cindy Sheehan’s (2015) book entitled, “The Obama Files: Chronicles of an Award-Winning War Criminal.” He is interviewed and quoted in former U.S. Congresswoman and 2008 Green Party presidential nominee Dr. Cynthia McKinney’s 2015 Ph.D. dissertation (Antioch University) entitled, “El No Murio, El Multiplico! Hugo Chavez: The Leadership and the Legacy on Race.” He is in the archives of Dr. Huey P. Newton (Stanford University, CA), cofounder of the Black Panther Party. For more about Larry Pinkney, see the book, “Saying No to Power: Autobiography of a 20th Century Activist and Thinker,” by William Mandel, introduction by Howard Zinn. (Click http://www.blackactivistwg.org/blog/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/struggle-and-win.net-Bill-Mandel-on-Larry-Pinkney.pdf, “Bill Mandel on Larry Pinkney,” to read excerpts from the book.) Larry Pinkney can be reached at email@example.com.
Bill Mandel on Larry Pinkney: excerpts from ‘Saying No to Power’
by William Mandel
For four solid years, while I was researching and writing “Soviet But Not Russian,” my primary social activism was on behalf of prisoners. The credit is due them, for it was initiated by their letters stimulated by my broadcasts and sometimes deeply involving KPFA as a station.
Further conflict between me and the News Department arose out of my efforts for Larry Pinkney, a former Black Panther. His militancy started with his experiences as the only African-American student in a Maryland High School of three thousand, which had Ku Klux Klan agitators.
Years later, Pinkney had been appointed by San Francisco Mayor [Joseph] Alioto, under pressure from segments of the Black, white and Chicano communities, to the Civil Service Commission oral board interviewing candidates for the Fire Department. He had been the only Black member, the only civilian, the youngest.
Having lost the key to an apartment available to him, he tried to get in through a window. Police, tailing him, said as they seized him: “We have you now, nigger!” and beat him badly. He was convicted of burglary under the illegal-entry clause of the penal code.
Pinkney wrote me early in 1983, when completing in Vacaville a nine-year term that began in Canada. He is best described in a “To Whom It May Concern” letter about him from a member of the Canadian Parliament from the Conservative Party.
Canada had cooperated with the U.S. desire to imprison Larry after he fled this country subsequent to that frame-up in 1973. It was only after the U.N. Human Rights Committee officially condemned the actions of the Canadian government in his case that he was transferred to imprisonment in the U.S. in his seventh year of incarceration, instead of being released.
The Canadian M.P. wrote: “I am our Party’s spokesman on issues relating to Correction and Parole … I became acquainted with Mr. Larry Pinkney … I was quickly impressed with the high level of personal integrity which he displayed. He was not looking for any favours; he was not enumerating an inventory of complaints or alibis. In short, there was no evidence that he had ever become a part of the criminal sub-culture which makes up so much a part of our prison population … I have … found … him … meticulously honorable. My experience with him is that his word is his bond.”
I sent him [Pinkney] poems I had written in the early ‘50s, primarily about Black freedom struggles I had participated in. He wrote: “They made me feel love but, most of all, your poems make me feel hope. Your poem, ‘For My Children, To Dr. DuBois,’ is my favorite. Its strength lies in its combined gentleness and searing truthfulness; so powerful, yet so gentle.” …
A year after we became acquainted, [Pinkney] was framed for allegedly trying to start a riot in prison. None had occurred. In fact – I had been kept informed of the situation as it developed in the previous week – he was trying to stop one from developing.
When I told Bari Scott, the African-American woman who headed KPFA’s Third World Department, about the situation, she contacted U.S. Sen. Cranston’s and Congressmember Dellums’ offices.
I wrote the Vacaville warden and the head of the state prison system essentially identical letters: “I intend to broadcast on this matter…,” of course in my Soviet program time, “and to ask listeners to write you …
“I visited Mr. Pinkney last Monday. Mr. Pinkney was greatly troubled by events earlier that day. He had taken the lead in calming the situation, which required approximately four group meetings in the course of the day. He was proud of the fact that he enjoyed the confidence of white and Chicano inmates as well as Black, and that this had made it possible to cool the situation …
“The removal of peacemakers looks to me like a great way to guarantee a riot next time racial friction occurs. Is that what the authorities desire?”
I described the situation to the news director, who didn’t cover it. When I asked why, she replied that it had “slipped her mind.”
So I went to the African American woman heading the Third World Department, who contacted the (independent) KPFA Saturday News. They phoned me and broadcast a good story, ending with a request for communications to the authorities. On my own show, on which I gave the case five minutes at the start and two at the end, I got numerous phone calls from people who wanted to write.
Eight days after I informed the news director of the situation, she could no longer resist the pressure, accepted a call from Larry, and broadcast it on the 6 p.m. news. I wrote him: “Everyone commented on your articulateness.”
Rep. Dellums wrote the Vacaville warden protesting the violation of statewide prison rules in the Pinkney case, and saying that U.S. Sen. Cranston and a state senator had also had their mail to Pinkney opened. This stimulated a “To Whom It May Concern” letter from the public information department of the prison system saying they got “a large number of similar letters and postcards regarding the situation of Larry Pinkney. Correspondents apparently learned of Mr. Pinkney’s situation via a radio broadcast.”
Pinkney wrote me: “The reason I was found not guilty was not due to my firm presentation or even the witnesses in my defense. I was found not guilty due to the strong support from you, your listeners and other listeners to KPFA who contacted the California Dept. of Corrections [CDC].” …
Early 1984 saw the wrap-up of my controversy with KPFA News over its handling of Pinkney. At a staff meeting, I said that the news director’s failure to deal for eight days with the story that prison authorities were trying to discipline him for what was actually his role in preventing a riot was an act of racism.
In a memo written for circulation within Pacifica, I wrote: “I do not believe that [the news director] believes in slavery, lynching, segregation or discrimination. However, in a country in which the latter two are prevalent realities, plus regular police murder of Blacks, including young children, special sensitivity is demanded in any story where Blacks are involved, particularly in a situation in which the victim has a history of political militancy …
“Failure to act with such sensitivity is racist. I cannot avoid the conclusion that the very bad relationship between [the news director] and myself over my four and a half years of criticism of the News Department’s handling of Soviet matters played a role in her not acting on the story.”
For anyone with any doubt about why militant activists like Pinkney wound up in prison, the following excerpt from his FBI file, obtained under the Freedom of Information Act, speaks for itself: “Pinkney is potentially dangerous due to his demonstrated ability to unify black and white. His associates are Negro, White, and Chinese.
“Special attention is being given to neutralizing him. The areas of sex and drugs appear to be the most effective ones to utilize. His habits in these areas are unknown, but are being monitored with this objective. The FBI is working in conjunction with [blacked out, but a covering note to the U.S. Secret Service, San Francisco, accompanies this].”
Pinkney asked me to pick him up on his release. His parents lived in Washington, D.C., and he had a sister in the Northwest. “There are very few people indeed that I would want to be anywhere near on that day,” he wrote me, “as I doubt strongly that they would or could conceive of what it means to me, what I have been through, or my psychological state of mind. With you, however, there is no doubt that you know all these things far more poignantly than most people could ever know or hope to know.”
Larry’s indomitable spirit had come through most strongly in a letter to me describing a most unusual event behind prison walls: “When I heard that you were going to play that [HUAC hearing] recording, I did something that I have never done before [in over nine years behind bars]. I rounded up all the prisoners in my dorm and requested that they listen to it, which they did.
“They were elated hearing you do battle; and afterwards, there were many questions to me from the prisoners (both black and white) about what they had heard. They all clearly got the drift of what you were saying before HUAC, though they asked me to explain some of the words that you used after they heard it … They were cheering you on (something that utterly amazed me) … A couple of the prisoners are adamantly anti-communist; but even they were cheering you on … You got across even to people who have virtually no political astuteness at all.”
These excerpts and more can be found at http://www.blackactivistwg.org/blog/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/struggle-and-win.net-Bill-Mandel-on-Larry-Pinkney.pdf.